I have most of the Buffy ones- of course I'm never sure if those get to me because of the song, or because I can remember what happened showwise when the song was playing. The Sarah McL song at the end of Becoming II chokes me up anytime I hear it.
Buffista Music II: Wrath of Chaka Khan
There's a lady plays her fav'rite records/On the jukebox ev'ry day/All day long she plays the same old songs/And she believes the things that they say/She sings along with all the saddest songs/And she believes the stories are real/She lets the music dictate the way that she feels.
That was my next suggestion!
ETA- Hallelujah, that is. But 'Full of Grace' is my Pity Party Song Numero Uno.
Hee. Clearly I have chosen well so far.
I'm thinking of making a mix called "And Fade Out..." or something like that.
'The Promise' by Tracy Chapman? 'Cannonball' by Damien Rice?
I can have fun with this one.
Good Lilty! I have neither of those!
The Eva Cassidy version of "Fields of Gold"?
Ooo, good one, Lyra Jane!
The acoustic version of Sister Hazel's 'Your Mistake' is good.
I need to stop and go to work or I could do this all day.
Any ideas for strummy strummy aching love songs? Stuff like you might hear at the end of a tv drama to make you cry?
Oh, I've got tons of these. I've made entire tapes of this stuff, though it tends to be a bit more rootsy and a bit less singer/songwriter confessional. Still, plenty strummy. These tapes are all designed to cultivate melancholy.
IN THE PINES
A-SIDE: Women of Ireland - Laurie Lewis; Wayfaring Stranger - Emmylou Harris; Bargain Store - Dolly Parton; Blue Moon - Elvis Presley; Ain't No Ash Will Burn - Ranch Romance; Let the Mystery Be - Iris Dement; Every Time You Say Goodbye - Alison Krauss; Love Vigilantes - Oyster Band; I Don't Want to Spoil the Party - Rosanne Cash; Lullaby of London - June Tabor & The Oyster Band; Dirty Old Town - Pogues; When Will I Be Loved - Sandy Denny & Linda Thompson; Highway Kind - Townes Van Zandt; Hickory Wind - Emmylou Harris; Dallas - Flatlanders; Amazing Grace - Ron Wood
B-SIDE: On My Way to Kolozsvar Town - Marta Sebestyn; Streets of Sorrow - Pogues; Meet on the Ledge - Fairport Convention; Mo Ghile Mear - Mary Black; Snow Don't Fall - Townes Van Zandt; Whispering Pines - The Band; Brass Buttons - Gram Parsons; Shaking Hands (Soldier's Joy) - Michelle Shocked; The Light - Laurie Lewis; When the Circus Comes To Town - Los Lobos; Dark Skies - Alison Krauss; Finisterre - June Tabor & Oyster Band; Never Again - Richard & Linda Thompson; Drivin' on 9 - Ed's Redeeming Qualities; Black Eyed Dog - Nick Drake
BLACKWATER SIDE
A-SIDE: Mining for Gold - Cowboy Junkies; Kathleen - Townes Van Zandt; Jolene - Dolly Parton; Blackwater Side - Ann Briggs; Scarborough Settler's Lament - Stan Rogers; Bright Morning Star - Burns Sisters; Keeper of the Mountain - Flatlanders; My Life - Iris Dement; Here There and Everywhere -Emmylou Harris; She Moves Through the Fair - Carol Noonan; Second Lover's Song - Townes Van Zandt; Angel Eyes - Willis Alan Ramsey; Jesus Help Me To Stand - Alison Krauss; My Youngest Son Came Home Today - Mary Black; A Heart Needs a Home - Richard & Linda Thompson
B-SIDE: Our Mother the Mountain - Townes Van Zandt; Night Comes In - Richard Thompson; Lay This Body Down - June Tabor; Time of No Reply - Nick Drake; Fotheringay - Fairport Convention; Three Fishers - Stan Rogers; Troublesome Waters - Iris Dement; St. John The Gambler - Townes Van Zandt; Down Where the Drunkards Roll - Los Lobos; I Long For Your Kiss -Lucinda Williams; Slow Surprise - Emmylou Harris; Genesis Hall - June Tabor
DAYS
A-SIDE: Days - Kirsty McColl; Living Life - K. McCarty; Thirteen - Big Star; You And Your Sister - Chris Bell; Which Will - Lucinda Williams; Coming Back To Me - Rickie Lee Jones; Dumb - Nirvana; Holocaust - Kendra Smith/Rainy Day; Little Angel Little Brother - Lucinda Williams; Forever Nightshade Mary - Latin Playboys; Johnsburg, Illinois - Tom Waits; As Tears Go By - Marianne Faithful; I'll Keep It With Mine - Nico; All Tomorrow's Parties - June Tabor & The Oyster Band
B-SIDE: Dancing Barefoot - Patti Smith; State Trooper - Bruce Springsteen; Street Hassle: Waltzing Matilda - Lou Reed; Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams -Nico; Fruit Tree - Nick Drake; Four Seasons In One Day - Crowded House; Ringside - Pete Ham; Julia - Beatles; Linden Arden Stole the Highlights - Van Morrison; Nightswimming - REM; Outside this Bar - American Music Club; Rainbow Sleeves - Ricki Lee Jones; Farewell Farewell - Fairport Convention; End of a Holiday - Fairport Convention
Also, "She Calls Your Name" - Beth Orton and "With Tomorrow" - Gene Clark.