No worries...I brought it on myself by my shorthanding of what I meant.

Show not called The Scooby Gang, true, but because it's about Buffy every character on it should reflect (or refract?) her, in one way or another. Some should be what she could become if she chooses the good path, some should be what she could become if she chooses the evil path, some should represent things she wants but can't have, some should represent parts of her, etc. Some, like Spike, seem to offer an escape from the problems of being Buffy (s6) and then reflect her heroic choices back to her (S7). So I think it's cool that Lyra Jane mapped the Idea of Plei onto some of the other characters.

From Plei's original epiphany:

It's all about Power, but it's all about letting go of the things that have power over you.

And more recently:

given the time and desire to expand it beyond Buffy herself (and I think can be extended to Xander and Willow, but explicitly *NOT* to Spike, which is a story for another thread)

Sure you can, at least withing the seven seasons of Buffy (S5 AtS not included). At the end of S6 Spike went (supposedly) to seek his soul, because Buffy "made him weak." So he got his soul, his "power", but found out he still was weak. It was still "God help [him], all about you, Buffy." He didn't need to get the soul, he didn't need to get rid of it, he needed to let go of Buffy, because Buffy is who had power over him. Chosen, presumably, was showing him letting go of Buffy. He gave up his childish, high school (we met Spike in high school) things and the power they had over him. He used his power (the amulet) to let go of what had power over him (Buffy).

Well, as it's my theory, and I cannot view the character exclusive of the continuing arc, I think Chosen, more than Grave, indicates the beginning of his journey vis a vis letting go, not the end.

But my thoughts on Spike, as I said, belong in another thread.

(I'll hop over to Angel when I get back from a short jaunt to Canada and put them down there. It's all related, which is why I'm very, very insistent about leaving him out for the moment.)

(It's sort of a unified theory of ME.)

Far be it from me to dissuade you from completing your unified theory. And that's why I excluded S5 AtS. I don't really see that much of what has happened to Spike so far is carrying forward from Chosen. It seems mostly like regression. Hence, I'm very curious to see how you see Spike's journey progressing and how/if it pertains to the "power" theory. Also, how much that might change with future episodes of Angel.

I'll give you the short answer in Angel now.

Does anyone else besides me foolishly purchase the Buffy magazine ever other month when it comes out? They had a rating for the Season Finales for each season that was terribly off kilter to my reality.

Does anyone else besides me foolishly purchase the Buffy magazine ever other month when it comes out? They had a rating for the Season Finales for each season that was terribly off kilter to my reality.

I usually purchase it, but I cannot remember how they rated the finales.

Pathetic, that is how... I gotta go get it from my car to remember.

Prophecy Girl - B+ Becoming Pt 2 - A - Graduation Day Pt 2 - B + Restless - B The Gift - A Grave - B+ Chosen - A

----- Here's my opinion Prophecy Girl - A- Becoming Pt 2 - A+ Graduation Day Pt 2 - B- Restless - A+++ The Gift - B+ Grave - B- Chosen - A

I guess mine weren't all that different. I just took offense to Restless getting the lowest grade.

I just took offense to Restless getting the lowest grade.

With good reason. That is just insane. Restless is such a brilliant episode.