Does anyone else besides me foolishly purchase the Buffy magazine ever other month when it comes out? They had a rating for the Season Finales for each season that was terribly off kilter to my reality.
I usually purchase it, but I cannot remember how they rated the finales.
Pathetic, that is how... I gotta go get it from my car to remember.
Prophecy Girl - B+
Becoming Pt 2 - A -
Graduation Day Pt 2 - B +
Restless - B
The Gift - A
Grave - B+
Chosen - A
-----
Here's my opinion
Prophecy Girl - A-
Becoming Pt 2 - A+
Graduation Day Pt 2 - B-
Restless - A+++
The Gift - B+
Grave - B-
Chosen - A
I guess mine weren't all that different. I just took offense to Restless getting the lowest grade.
I just took offense to Restless getting the lowest grade.
With good reason. That is just insane. Restless is such a brilliant episode.
I would have trouble ranking them from most to least favorite. They are some of the best episodes in the series, imo and I love them all. Although I don't think that you can rate Grave separate from Two to Go.
True, the finales are usually great, Grave being the least so. But still good. The way I seperate TTG and Grave is one had much more Giles.
Grave just doesn't stack up for me compared to the rest...one of the top 20 ever, but not as good as the other finales. Maybe Graduation Day Pt 2 or Prophecy Girl, but not quite.
I love, love, love Grave. I'd put it second to Becoming among the finales.
(The rest would be Restless, Chosen, Prophecy Girl, Graduation Day and The Gift,in order.)