I haven't been reading or posting much here due to real life issues but it was kind of a blessing to go into the finale "clean". Buffistas are so bright and articulate that I often find myself swayed by their opinions. Sometimes when I'm reading I feel like one of those bobblehead dolls, just sitting and nodding at the screen. I went into the finale with only my own, admittedly low, expectations. And I loved/hated the finale.
I laughed at the Angel/Buffy/Spike ("He wears lifts." hee) At the same time I had a "He's here just for that moment and a "What about Cordy?" moment. But hey, hoyay!
I laughed and cringed at the party in Xander's eye. I loved D&D!Giles. Heck, I just loved Giles again period. At the same time, I thought "What happened to crap!Giles?" and "Why did they make us go through that again."
I thought the Spuffy was handled with grace. I definitely thought they had "the sex" and I was ok with it. At the same time, I wondered why they couldn't have given us more of that great characterization before.
I started crying as soon as Anya took off with her little monkey. And what a perfect death for her. At the same time, I would have liked to have seen someone other than Andrew care a little bit about the fact that she'd died. If not for her sake, then at least for Xander.
I loved the hot Faith/Wood (and McHottie is sooo prettier than Faith). At the same time, couldn't you have made the Faith/Wood sex that good?
I could go on, but then I realized that I just had to take the finale on its own merits. If I start picking at it in light of all the things I didn't like about this season, the whole thing is just gonna unravel for me. I don't want that because, while I was watching, I did love this episode.
Willow told Xander to roll with the pirate look! Dawn kicked Buffy! Buffy saw the hoyay! Giles shook his head in that Giles-y way and watched his charges march off to save the world again! Andrew did a good, good thing (and got Xander to touch him-- banner day for him)! Spike saved the world! Buffy told Spike she loved him and I didn't feel like tearing my hair out! Some little girl is about to knock the hell out of a softball! So many good things.
And Buffy smiled again. A real one. And we don't know what's gonna happen next, but I'd like to know. I want to see how Wood surprises Faith. I want to see Dawn, Jr. Watcher. I want to watch Willow, badass good witch. I want to see them gathering up potentials from all over. I won't see this (sniff) but I want to. I still care after seven seasons, countless big bads (and that's just the fashion faux pas), the plural of apocalypse. That's an achievement.
So, I won't nitpick today. Can't promise about tomorrow. Today, I'll just say thanks ME. Job well done.