5 Funniest:

1) Tall Tales: For those of you who have not heard the story, I watched this in a Seattle hotel room with Jilli, Cass, and Plei, then we hung out and watched vids for a bit, then we walked down to the valet to collect the car, and were still laughing so hard that the valet seemed dubious about giving us the car. GOOD TIMES!

For the rest, it's pretty much for the same reasons as what ita said.
Changing Channels:
Hollywood Babylon:
Bad Day At Black Rock:
Monster Movie: Lederhosen!

Tall Tales: Lady in Red dancing scene.

He really didn't seem sure that I was okay to drive. The fact we kept bursting into laughter for no apparent reason likely did not help. Good times...

Not a list.

If you're tired of the spam, please say so. But I share because I love.

1.01 picspam, with commentary.

S1 top five:

1. Asylum. I still flinch when Sam shoots Dean, I can't help it! But their dynamic, Sam's rebellious resentment, the utter creeptasticness of the thing!

2. Dead in the Water. Which I always type as Dean in the water. That insight into Dean as a kid, Amy Acker in a bathtub!

3. Nightmare. The first time I felt a serious HSQ moment with the show was when Max's connection to Sam is revealed.

4. Home. THAT PHONE CALL. THEIR LITTLE FACES.

5. Devil's Trap. OMGDEMONJOHN. Ahem.

Positions and presence subject to change on whim.

If you're tired of the spam, please say so. But I share because I love.

I love the sharing.

eta: Some of those moments with commentary got me a little misty.

As far as non-Lucifer explanations for the streetlight, my favorite is that Sam's a ghost. That sort of environmental response is totally within the realm of what we've seen around ghosts.

Much as I love Whoopi, I'd really rather they not communicate through a third party.

It does fit with the street lamp, but I hope that isn't the case.

Ghost Sam could bring the angst though.