They could have re-imagined Muffit as a cave bear!

I have to laugh at the thought of most of these people surviving the first winter. They don't know what's safe to eat or even touch, they are apparently avoiding the locals, who could give them information (shades of the Prime Directive with all its sticky colonialistic paternalism), and they're giving up on really important knowledge and technology.

Dumb.

Also, my Tivo cut out in the scene where Bill was sitting on a hilltop talking to dead!Laura. What happened after that?

Loving all the 'that was a bad plan' realism from the Buffistas. I get the cabin fever rationalization, but no tools other than what they can carry? Whuhuh? Haven't any of them watched Earth 2, for goodness sakes? Cargo pods make efficient living quarters.

I can see not wanting to contaminate any existing cultures...ala Prime Directive...but with all the technology available, they couldn't build sensors or something?

Baltar's, "I know about farming" choke-up caught me so off guard, I sobbed out loud. Nicely done.

I agree with the dissatisfaction over the resolution of Hera's purpose upthread. It seemed as if Adama's 'she's valuable and we'll fight to the death for her (actually) was a battle cry for its own sake. Though, I suppose, if you are going to go down, might as well go down hard.

Must rewatch.

I don't suppose it matters, but I wonder if other SCC viewers thought that Derek really pulled the trigger. I'm leaning toward yes...

I wonder if other SCC viewers thought that Derek really pulled the trigger.

I think he really really wanted to, but in the end let his obedience to John overrule him. Kind of a marker of the way John's actually becoming John Connor, but one who won't think of human life as disposable or a distraction.

As someone in my LJ pointed out, not knowing whether Jesse is dead allows them to bring her back later, and leave us unsure whether it's Jesse or a Terminator.

John really became John Conner, didn't he? Sort of a second evolution. Impressive.

That's a good thought Consuela. My only reason for my thinking he did shoot was Derek's insistance on saving John from himself...not to mention the shocking betrayl by his one true love. Then again, John figuring her scheme out, just by looking at the body, really spoke to John Conner coming into his own mind.

leave us unsure whether it's Jesse or a Term

Oooh. When they left it open, I said to myself...she better not just show up later because they like the actor, or whatever. BUT, if the squiggly metal could become her (without skewering her...is that possible?) then that changes everything. Hmmm.

I think the metal Terminators from the movie could become pretty much anything they wanted.

And it's possible that the T2000s Have A Plan for her.

Aaaand, still not impressed by the finale of BSG.

In the end, though, Lee's flashbacks had the best narrative structure, because they bookended his relationship with Kara. Tigh and Ellen's flashbacks to him being obnoxiously drunk? Okay, there was Ellen declaring her love and wanting to be with him no matter where, just with. I could step back and say it was appropriate for the characters to be at a strip joint and annoyingly drunk, but on the whole, narratively, jarring.

Adama and Roslin was lovely, and made me cry, but I'm still wtf over him going off forever to die alone and never see his son again.

NOBODY HAS SUPPLIES!!!! I think Baltar had the biggest rucksack.

There were so many things that didn't work, and hearing Ron Moore in The Last Frakkin' Special describe his trouble over the plot, and then happily declaring "we don't need a plot, it's about the characters!" makes me want him to turn blue. So many moments during the action where I was "wait, how did they get there? How did the fleet know of Kara's super seekrit Bob Dylan coordinates? Why didn't they do this before and then immediately do that after?!" And then the quieter "character" moments were so disjointed and left me cold.

Also, where was Adama and Saul's goodbye? Huh? HUH?!