Oz ,'Same Time, Same Place'
A thread to discuss naming threads, board policy, new thread suggestions, and anything else that has to do with board administration and maintenance. Guaranteed to include lively debate and polls. Natter discouraged, but not deleted.
Current Stompy Feet: ita, Jon B, DXMachina, P.M. Marcontell, Liese S., amych
That sounded snotty, Jesse. I'm sorry. I was actually hoping some more people will be around before midnight to weight in, especially ita, since she thought it was confusing.
I personally am fine with postponing the vote for a day but a) what I said above re:already annoucing it and b) I felt like I made a promise I would pst, so I would want more people wanting to wait than just us!
No, I know just what you're saying, Sophia! I have to go to bed, though. So I dunno what to do.
Well, unless more people weigh in I am going to post as is. I will note at the top that we MAY extend the voting period if people are rushed. I will note that peoples issues will be heard in bureaucracy as well.
OK - a question on Item 4. I think seven days total is enough. But I don't think discussion should be closed once voting starts. In other words all seven days should be discussion, though obviously once voting starts the text can't change. So given the wording - do I vote yes or no on Item 4? Because it looks like if 4 wins, discussion is closed once voting starts.
Good one, good one! I think I hate having to mush together a pseudo-process to decide the damn process.
I will just note that this is a very odd definition of a seven days. We did not start formal discussion until Monday. Voting will close Friday (or is it Saturday). I have trouble getting seven days out of this.
I'm fine with extending the voting period, but I'd note that the vote to decide how to vote doesn't have to work the way item 4 says. Because we haven't yet decided that's how we want to do things. ;)
My automated email ballot is looking good, by the way. I should be able to show you folks something soon.
(How do you put in a carriage return/new line in PHP? It's not \n)
So given the wording - do I vote yes or no on Item 4? Because it looks like if 4 wins, discussion is closed once voting starts.
You vote no. The item presents one option. If you don't want that option, vote no. If enough people vote no, we keep discussing it.
OK - a question on Item 4. I think seven days total is enough. But I don't think discussion should be closed once voting starts. In other words all seven days should be discussion, though obviously once voting starts the text can't change. So given the wording - do I vote yes or no on Item 4? Because it looks like if 4 wins, discussion is closed once voting starts.
Should we add a note about voting later as to whether discussion should be allowed the whole time?
The reason I said above is that I personally could envision 4 days of discussion, ironing out the final wording of the proposal AND discussing it. The 3 days of voting, where the discussion could continue, but nothing would change the proposal.
Lyra Jane suggested am alternative Jesse. See Lyra Jane "Bureaucracy 1: Like Kafka, Only Funnier" Feb 25, 2003 4:49:34 pm EST
I would amend #4 as follows:
A yes vote on this item signifies the voter agrees that a full week's time is sufficient to discuss the issue. The week would be broken down thusly: Discussion: Days 1, 2, 3, and 4. Voting: Days 5, 6, 7. When there is a conflict for major holidays (to be defined) we will make accomodations (to be defined) as needed. We will vote later on whether discussions end on day 4 or continue during the votes.