She plays it from the house phone in the kitchen--it's a cordless handset in it's recharging base--using the base speaker.

You're right. My point was that it was from a phone and not from a CD. It looked like she called into her voicemail and got it. I suppose it's possible that Keith has her pin, but it would surprise me.

It's not how the technical method he used to get the message onto CD that bothers me; it's how he got access to the message in the first place.

He hit the redial button, and he learned what the PIN was by listening to the tones. Because, uhm, he's Keith Mars!

I don't think Keith mixed up the CDs, but I am irritated that in this episode and the one with the fat guy rolling up on the beach their script editor isn't watching for this stuff. If there's a CD that's a big part of one scene and a CD that's a big part of the next scene and you have to guess that the next scene's CD is different-- use a freaking minitape.

You know, if I were Keith Mars -- or at least a parent with a daughter who'd been through so much as Veronica, and seemed as likely to see out danger -- I'd have my kid in serious therapy. And drive her to the appointment and wait in the waiting room every week.

What I was trying to say earlier was when Keith said something about "This investigation...", my immediate reaction was "Oh, Keith is secretly carrying on his own investigation into the bus crashtacular. Much like he did for young Lilly Kane. It isn't much like Keith to involve the sherriff in every little aspect.

Double post because of a double espresso. My mistakes.

Teddy Dunn actually did a smashing job

Agreed.

I was shocked to realize that when Veronica/Duncan suffers its sudden yet inevitable demise, I will be sad.

I will too. Duncan is growing on me in a big way. Especially because he is trying to patch things up with Logan and because he didn't react with jealousy when Veronica ran to break up Jackie and Logan. (I love me some enraged!Veronica.)

I thought Keith gave Lamb the voicemail message.

Alicia was really dumb to not make more effort to explain to Wallace what she did and why especially regrading the letters/lying about giving his Dad a choice - but just taking off with your sketchy-past-having BioDad across country? That's ker-azee. Is Wallace 18? Would BioDad be worried about kidnapping charges?

So - I was packing while I watched and didn't tape - did Jackie tell the Psychic about Lilly? I thought I heard her deny it, but who else would? And Lilly wouldn't actually be pissed about Veronica/Logan - would she?

raspberries and yogurt:

I just saw this:

OUT OF THIS WORLD: It appears the stars have finally aligned for Veronica Mars. UPN's little show that could attracted 3.6 million viewers last night — its largest audience to date. Mars no doubt got an assist from ABC, which aired a Lost rerun instead of an original. It also doesn't hurt that the show is, well, really good.

So - I was packing while I watched and didn't tape - did Jackie tell the Psychic about Lilly? I thought I heard her deny it, but who else would? And Lilly wouldn't actually be pissed about Veronica/Logan - would she?

Jackie said she hadn't. But really, if the psychic lived or worked in Neptune she would know all about Lilly Kane and Veronica Mars and Logan Echolls--Veronica was with Logan when Logan was on trial, after all. So she could've gotten the information from the news.

I honestly don't know if Ghost!Lilly would be pissed. Mostly I think she'd think it was hysterical.

So she could've gotten the information from the news.

Good point.

Mostly I think she'd think it was hysterical.

That's what I was thinking.