I didn't like any of the male characters is "Pretty in Pink." None of them. I so wanted Molly Ringwald's character to reject them all. I could not stand them.
"Some Kind of Wonderful" I liked better, but it was much thinner on plot and realism than the previous movies. The ending of course was unrealistic.
The thing with Xander is that we aren't really rooting for him like we are supposed to for the lead character of SKOW. So I think it is okay to like him some times and not others (especially Season 6).
My favorite character in Pretty in Pink was Annie Potts. And I sort of assumed Ducky was gay, maybe even before I knew what gay was.
My favorite character in Pretty in Pink was Annie Potts.
Until she rejects her cool vintage style to be some Yuppie's girlfriend!
I don't remember: did Xander keep his romantic intentions secret from Buffy? If he did disclose, are the romantic intentions in someone who is just friends still NiceGuy behavior?
Isn't high school all about romantic intentions misplaced--college too for that matter? Or was that just my experience.
I don't remember: did Xander keep his romantic intentions secret from Buffy?
He asked her out and got rejected in "Prophecy Girl."
I don't remember Xander being passive-aggressive w/r/t Buffy. Anya, later on, yes, but not Buffy (and I don't remember that he was with Cordelia either - that was more aggressive-aggressive on both sides).
I'm totally not getting the Nice Guy support citations for Xander over most of his relationships. Sure, he failed to get the girl sometimes, and he fucked other shit up, but not like a Nice Guy.
I should clarify that I don't think passive-aggressive behavior necessarily equals Nice Guy behavior. It certainly can be, but I don't think it was in Xander's case.
In my personal fanon of SKOW,Annie Potts' character tries out "normal" till she breaks up with that guy and goes Goth.
But I can also imagine her being Ducky's Mrs. Robinson...is that gross?