I don't think Frankenbuddha (and I'm sorry to step into the middle of this, but here I go anyway) said anything about Allyson "dissing" Firefly all over the thread". I think what he said is that she's been "dissing it in passive-aggressive terms for months now" [paraphrased], which while may give the same impression as "all over the thread" is actually quite different.

If I may make so bold, he's mentioning what I've also noticed, which is that Allyson may've been more subtextually than actually "dissing" Firefly (although being "Fireflyed out" may not be a literal slam, to some of us it does not advertise the true love and obsession that many of us share).

Not knowing many people here, like, up close and personal, over years of board and RL interaction, I do feel I know enough about basic forum life (that would be the "general forum"-forum, rather than specifically "Buffistas forum"-forum, btw), to kinda read a situation. I don't think Frankenbuddha was tryin' ta start anything, merely curious as to why Allyson's attitude toward Firefly may be such as it appears to be.

(Enough caveats? Addendums? Covered my ass completely yet?)

I think this: "I'm not really interested in the movie" kind of thing may have been what Frankenbuddha was referring to.

I'm positive Frankenbuddha can speak for himself, and it is not my intention to get in the middle of anybody's shit and interfere, no way. I am simply posting my opinion on the current situation, as it appears from the outside, and honestly? I don't see any reason on any side to take offense. A question was asked, I thought sincerely, and if I am wrong in my reading of this in any way, that's just because I, too, make mistakes.

I know, I know. Shocking! Rare, but it can happen.

I'll get out of the way now. Thank you for your time and I apologize for the inconvenience.

I don't get why anyone needs to be interested in the movie. In fact, there are posters on the board who actively disliked the show and care not one whit about the upcoming movie.

And have said so.

Why is anyone being quizzed having ODed on a show she put a hell of a lot of effort into?

I think it's a miracle Allyson still watches any TV at all, myself, and don't see it surprising (or worth asking for explanation) when most people say they're whatevered out.

Ree, I haven't seen her diss it here in the past four months. Passive aggressively or aggressively. So I'm assuming it happened somewhere else, or in the deeper past. And I'm curious about where, more than anything, and about the relevance of her actually being excited about The Inside.

Allyson doesn't do ANYTHING passive-aggressively (thank God). She's just not all that jazzed about the film. That has nothing to do with the film and all to do with her own feelings. I AM jazzed and don't share her feelings, but why should I? I'd hate for her to be dishonestly enthusisastic if that's not what she feels. One of the things I prize so highly about this place is that people share their honest opinion about things. Jessica and I disagree all the time in the movies thread, but I love reading her opinions because she is smart and passionate, just like Allyson. Not everyone has to love what I love. The fact that 95% of the folks on this board are indifferent about The Avengers won't change the fact that I love the show and won't affect the enjoyment I get from it.

The fact that 95% of the folks on this board are indifferent about The Avengers won't change the fact that I love the show and won't affect the enjoyment I get from it.

What? Can that possibly be true? 95% indifferent to the hottitude of Emma Peel? the casual elegance of John Steed? Hard to believe.

signed,
I want to be Emma Peel

I KNOW, Burrell! Shocking, isn't it?

Well, just a comment - this is the Firefly/Serenity Worship thread, yes? So, uh, it does come across as a little passive/aggressive to be even mildly anti in this thread.

And while I can't speak for anybody else, that does seem a little....odd to me. (Although I do understand enough to realize that Allyson has benefit of some insider's information that might not otherwise be available to the rest of us, and therefore the possibility that she might contribute more than a mild dissaffection - although even that may be overstating the case - makes her posts interesting to me.)

Not that I think there ought to be thread policing and the booting of persons not breathlessly awaiting Serenity from said thread. Just merely that if it is noticeable to peripatetic lurkers and semi-random participants such as myself, I can understand why it might be a bit more obvious to somebody else.

I'm not trying to imply that Allyson may or may not be a bad person for not being a Serenity wingnut, either.

Gawd. I'm trying to walk a fine line here - being fairly uninvolved in the whole Buffistas thing and not having the history here that others might, I am completely and utterly aware that I've probably stepped in muck up to my hips. I don't know people here that well, and I am pretty neutral on the whole "did she or didn't she" issue, to be completely honest, but then again, if I can see it, perhaps there's the possibility that others have seen it too.

Again, not convinced it's either good or bad, it's just observable.

Anyway. I think I'll bug out of this one from now on. I've thrown in my two cents, let the interest accrue. ;-D

Well, just a comment - this is the Firefly/Serenity Worship thread, yes?

No. God no. We don't have "worship" threads, in fact, I can go on at length in here about how badly The Trainjob blew, and I'm exactly in the right thread for that.

I do need some clarity on what Frank is saying, because he's bothered by my apathy or what he sees as passive aggressive swipes, and I can't address his feelings until I'm less puzzled.

Like ita, the most fascinating part was that he twice brought up The Inside:

>OK Allyson, I've been avoiding this, but, seriously, you've been dissing the SERENITY movie in passive/agressive terms for months while you've been pimping The Inside (and really, there is no other term for it, though, YES, I'm jonesing for it like all the other Minear-heads).

And then:

>It's not anything to do with THE INSIDE that bothers me, but the putting down of SERENITY that seems to be there bothers me in comparison. It may be imagined, but Allyson's comments on the movie haven't been much in the positive mode.

It bothers Frank that I'm "putting down" Serenity in comparison to "pimping" The Inside.

Is it a weird BNF issue? Am I supposed to blindly cheerlead every Whedon or Minear project?

I just need more adjectives and a couple of verbs and nouns from Frank to address his feelings and discuss it with him.

No. Worship. Threads.

Discussion threads, no worship. Not here. That's not ... not right.

Here are the posts of Allyson's in this thread (I'm too lazy to go back into the previous thread, but it'd be nice if there were cites from the people who see the dissing):

Allyson - Jan 5, 2005 10:20:33 am PST #235 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

OMG. I just added another $100 to my Amazon shopping cart of the cutest kids books. Two of them about stinky dogs, a couple about monsters, and one or two about being grumpy.

CUTE CUTE CUTE!!!!!

Thanks all for the recommendations.

Allyson - Jan 8, 2005 11:31:43 pm PST #266 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

Tamara, this ad?

I think it's 12/9

Allyson - Jan 30, 2005 11:43:45 am PST #457 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

On the other hand, I'm terribly afraid the suits will muck it up, and I want to see Joss's vision intact.

There's always the Director's Cut on DVD.

Allyson - Feb 3, 2005 9:52:20 am PST #487 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

So the world isn't really as full of stupid people as I think it is?

Allyson - Feb 3, 2005 8:17:58 pm PST #541 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

I am home. I am having soup and bread for supper, and screw the diet, I WILL HAVE THE VANILLA ICE CREAM AND HOT BUTTERSCOTCH.

Allyson - Feb 3, 2005 8:20:24 pm PST #542 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

Oh. And this is TOTALLY the wrong thread.

Allyson - Feb 8, 2005 4:44:20 pm PST #651 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

Sure, talk bad story about a Firefly actor. You could kill a thread, too.

I think he's sort of a wingnut, Gus. I'll stand by that.

Allyson - Mar 21, 2005 2:30:59 pm PST #963 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

Simon!

That's all I got.

Allyson - Apr 5, 2005 3:13:54 pm PDT #1018 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

I think I'm all Fireflyed out.

Allyson - Apr 13, 2005 12:13:11 pm PDT #1056 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

NO ONE ASKED ME TO WRITE ANYTHING.

Hurrumph. See if I try and save your next show, Whedon.

I'm so breaking up with you.

Allyson - Apr 22, 2005 5:21:30 pm PDT #1250 of 1266
I don't care about the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

I got an email from the serenity site, and the heading was, "A Message from Joss"

I remember way back when he used to just come and post. Thems were the days.

I think I'll unsubscribe, because it freaked me out. It's like those broadcast emails I get from the head honcho, A MESSAGE FROM THE ADMINISTRATOR

I'm such a rebel. I have those forwarded to the trash bin.

I think Allyson's been passive-aggressively dissing the Pan Pacific Grand Prix.

God, that formatting killed me.

Also, the Fireflyed out commente seemed to be a response to the Firefly comic. But I dunno.

I gotta agree with PC. It's the Grand Prix she's dissing.