But how about reviewing the album, and not sniping about iPod ads and putting a bunch of "Bono thinks he's God" jokes at the end?
Ugh. Yeah, that would bug.
The EW review wasn't stellar either, but it was still on the positive side.
I think the EW critic (and I don't have the magazine here, so I could be way wrong) basically felt that this was a perfectly good U2 album, but not a "we're gonna take apart our sound, and put it together in a shinier way, and CONQUER THE WORLD once more" album like ""The Joshua Tree" or "Achtung Baby" or even, to some extent, '"All That You Can't Leave Behind." Which I actually don't disagree with. It's a good album, maybe even a near-great one. But it's safely Joshua Tree/ATYCLB-esque, and this is a band that hasn't been interested in safe sounds, historically. So I love it for what it is, but at the same time wish they'd kept going with the electronica and experimentation a little more.
And '70's Elton John is frigging awesome. He had a very good run. he can still pull it out once in a while. (See; "I Want Love," from a few years ago.)
I think that's an apt comparison, P-C. I should go back and read it again, if I'm going to rail against it. I know my reaction was very knee-jerk. But on the other hand, I don't think I want to waste my time on something that upsets me irrationally.
And Lyra, I always wonder when reading reviews of U2 albums if expectations are just too high. Maybe they've made the album THEY wanted to make, rather than what the music world expects of them.
Personally, I want them to make the records THEY want to make, because then they're more likely to continue caring about the music, and perform better shows.
I'm no U2 fan, but Jim DeRogatis is a certifiable idiot, so if he doesn't like the album that's probably a good sign.
Hec, your book arrived yesterday. I only flipped through it, but so far, it's pretty cool. And it looks great.
Angus, I took you up on your Streets challenge a long time ago, but I never posted the results. I did find (after a couple of listens to get used to the accent and language) that it was a moving album, but it didn't move me to tears.
it was a moving album, but it didn't move me to tears
Catching part of a video for one of the Street's songs made me tear up in the junior dept. at Nordstroms recently. He looked so sad! And there was a sad dog too!
Signed,
Easy Weeper
Free Pixies mp3!
"Debaser"
So, a good time to check out the Pixies if you're not familiear with them. "Debaser" is one of my favorite Pixies songs too. It mentions that scene in Un Chien Andalou (by Salvador Dali and Luis Bunuel) where the eyeball gets sliced by a razor....
Debaser is one of the best songs ever. I still remember the moment when I realized that it was mentioning Un Chien Andalou ...
Anyway, I just ordered 40 copies of Lost in the Grooves. Of course, it was for the book signing, but still!
I still remember the moment when I realized that it was mentioning Un Chien Andalou ...
Once I was wondering if "Debaser" was refering to that scene. Then I asked myself, "How many other movies have a scene with a eyeball being slized by a razor?"
edit to make a little more sense....
