I wouldn't feel guilty about love of any Beatles album.

Not feeling guilty about my strange and deep love of Let it Be.

I know you love the music you love, but it feels like in here, it's the only music worth listening to.

I don't like that others feel this thread is hostile to mainstream music tastes. My feeling is that lots of folks have posted about mainstream artists in this thread and while it sometimes meets no discussion, so do lots of other posts about obscure artists that others have nothing to comment on other than "I've heard of that guy. Hmm."

Just heard: Brando died.

Wow.

I went and worked on a cost-benefit analysis and now I feel much calmer.

Ah. Never underestimate the soothing effects of the cost-benefit analysis I always say.

Anyway, what did y'all think about Pitchfork's Top Albums of the 70s list? I didn't think that it was half-bad, given that I think most of the contributors were born in the 80s. But it gives waaaaay too much credit to Bowie (looking at you, Jim).

I was slightly miffed to read in the intro graph that there was no Springsteen on the list. But on further reading, it's not a bad list. I would have more to say on that but it is POURING rain here and I am listening to Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots for the first time in forever and am caught up in perfect-rainy-album listening joy.

Joe, I'm willing to listen to the case for Lennon (and "In My Life" is a nice enough song), but the general fact is still that the Beatles have never moved above pleasant background music for me. I recognize that 95 percent of the rock fans in the world disagree.

About Hec, in particular, is the most absurd thing I've read in a long time. The guy wrote a book about the fricking Archies.

I hate to say this, but I do sometimes feel like Hec's thing is liking stuff very few people listen to anymore, or have heard at all. Which I respect, since I have my own tendencies to adore the obscure. But Archies love is not mainstream in 2004. If he wrote a book about 3-11, that might make your case :-).

I would love to see more people in here. Love it.

The New York Dolls are reuniting!!!

The New York Dolls, for those playing along at home, were an underground 70s band. Huge influence on the Sex Pistols, and the entire birth of British punk, and I have to think on Bowie and the birth of glamrock as well, given their gender-bending appearance.

Also responsible for spawning Buster Poindexter. But let's not discuss that.

Ah. Never underestimate the soothing effects of the cost-benefit analysis I always say.

So true. Someone should stitch that into a pillow.

I was slightly miffed to read in the intro graph that there was no Springsteen on the list. But on further reading, it's not a bad list.

That's how I felt when I read that Pere Ubu didn't make the list. Heck, I still think they could've cut Scary Monsters in favor of The Modern Dance.

I have to think on Bowie and the birth of glamrock as well, given their gender-bending appearance.

I'm pretty sure that's touched upon in the book "Please Kill Me", but it's been awhile since I've read it.

The New York Dolls, for those playing along at home, were an underground 70s band. Huge influence on the Sex Pistols, and the entire birth of British punk, and I have to think on Bowie and the birth of glamrock as well, given their gender-bending appearance.

But Jerry Nolan and Johnny Thunders are dead. It's kinda like that MC5 minus two version that's touring now. Or the very idea of the Who without Keith Moon.

Or Pink Floyd without Syd. ;)

If he wrote a book about 3-11

311! Unlike me, they have no hyphen. And I'm a fan.

Anyway, what did y'all think about Pitchfork's Top Albums of the 70s list?

It's not a bad list, but you'd think Carole King's Tapestry would get into the top 100.

I hate to say this, but I do sometimes feel like Hec's thing is liking stuff very few people listen to anymore, or have heard at all.

I disagree with this. And not to pick apart Hec with out him being here, but I think he has a bottomless pit of music crack-like addiction love that all of the compilation CDs in all of the Virgin megastores and obscure music shops of the coolest cities ever could not fill. Be it mainstream or nobody-has-ever-heard-of-it-before. Others people likes or dislikes, I don't think come into it, IMO.

I would love to see more people in here. Love it.

This I agree with, however.