but isn't better that they tackle these things head on?
But they didn't tackle anything.
Attempted Rape.
Mystical Magical Sunblocking Flying Motorcycle to Africa to Get a Soul
Gee Buffy, Spike Tried to Rape You
Yeah, but it was no Big. 'Sides, he went and Soulified, Dawnie!
He has a soul.
He has a soul.
He has a soul.
Crazy Basement Spike.
Annoyed Buffy.
Too Many Potentials.
Spike turns water into wine and dies for our sins.
Everything at Mutant Enemy seems to have fallen apart in 6-7. Folks confuse the word "dark" with the word, "crap."
S7 was well dodgy, but I still think S6 was one of the best.
Did you watch from Season one, on? Or did you become a fan later in the series?
I watched from season one, and I flat disagree with your readig of the last two seasons. Sure, they were messy (although I don't object to them just dumping the AR when they realised what a sore point it was) but they were the most inventive and unconventional seasons.
I guess the only mitigating factor that the writers could pull out for the attempted rape seem to be that "Spike was drunk, alcohol is a depressant, remember what happened to Angel when he got drugged? Angelus came out to play."
It wouldn't make it alright, but they didn't even try to play that card. At least if it had been brought up, it could have been discussed as a possible attempt at explaination.
But that only worked with Angel because the drug was some sort of agent that made him feel euphoric (not a depressant), thereby I dunno - sorta tricking him into feeling like his soul was gone.
(IOW - that one took a lot of wankery, too)
I guess the only mitigating factor that the writers could pull out for the attempted rape seem to be that "Spike was drunk, alcohol is a depressant, remember what happened to Angel when he got drugged? Angelus came out to play."
Except that Angel's soul was restored by a curse that would steal the soul away again if Angel experienced true happiness. (Hence the euphoria drug.) As far as we know, Spike's soul was simply restored, without the "true happiness" clause. So happy pills wouldn't work on him like that.
(IOW - that one took a lot of wankery, too)
ITA. It did.
But why would they have wanted mitigating factors in SR at all? They needed Spike to have a moment of clarity about his being a soulless being -- impossible to have that happen if he could blame his behavior on any outside force.
Mitigating factor for how Buffy behaved in S7, not for what Spike did in Seeing Red maybe.