My Name is Earl
I am obviously an enthusiastic watcher. Revised proposal:
This proposal is for the creation of two new threads.
1: Procedurals thread, to include Bones, House, Criminal Minds, and other Mystery of the Week formatted shows.
YES, NO, NP
1a: Should there be whitefont in this thread?
YES, NO
1b: If "yes" passes in 1a, what should the whitefont policy be?
24 hour whitefont, 72 hour whitefont, NP
2: Comedy thread.
YES, NO, NP
2a: Should the Comedy thread be only for network comedy programs (The Office, How I Met Your Mother, My Name is Earl) or for all comedy programs (including Comedy Central programs)?
Network Comedy, All Comedy, NP
2b: Should there be whitefont in this thread?
YES, NO
2c: If "yes" passes in 2b, what should the whitefont policy be?
24 hour whitefont, 72 hour whitefont, NP
Add in NP for the whitefont question and I think it's perfect.
Yeah, Jon, if you could add NP to the whitefont question too, please.
Sorry, I was away from my 'puter. I might not get to this until tomorrow morning.
The Press announcement is up:
Voting Has Begun!
And with that, I close this thread.
Aimee has proposed the following:
I propose that we close the dedicated Firefly thread and continue our discussions in the Minearverse thread.
Aimée "Bureaucracy 4: Like Job. No, really, just like Job" Oct 25, 2007 6:04:23 am PDT
As someone who couldn't stand Firefly, but does follow Tim's career, I'm naturally against the proposal, so I want to ask:
Do Serenity and the much-hoped-for-and-constantly-debated sequel really relate to Tim?
If we're closing the FF thread, I'd prefer the discussion be moved to Minearverse over Box Set. There is already some contentiousness going on regarding the content of the Box Set and spoiler issues and adding Firefly to the mix won't help. Minearverse is 1) fitting thematically as FF is a Tim show as much as a Joss show, and 2) it's much less problematic, spoiler-wise, since alas, there aren't any new Tim shows on air right now, as opposed to Box Set, which has something like 5-6 active shows being discussed at a given moment.
I think Minearverse and Other Media are perfectly appropriate places for Firefly, and possibly better, since I don't know that the FF thread has all that many followers anymore, even among those who remember it fondly. Even leaving that aside, I think the time for a dedicated thread has passed.
