I've read here that Heroes overwhelms the thread, while to me SPN does. To some it might seem BSG is the dominant discussion.

This is my current question. On a day where I had more brain, I'd just threadsuck and count, but I lack everything required to do so. Is any show dominating clearly? If so...is that even bad, for the people who watch it, and the people who don't?

Is any show dominating clearly?

t cough Supernatural.

But that's only my perspective because I don't watch it, and I watch most of the rest of what's discussed. Large numbers of posts are generally only a problem if you don't watch the show.

I'm kind of dubious about the premium/basic split, although I don't participate in the current Premium thread, so my dubiosity is based on exactly nothing.

But that's only my perspective because I don't watch it, and I watch most of the rest of what's discussed. Large numbers of posts are generally only a problem if you don't watch the show.

Except for that one watch n' post last week, I find that when I check at 10pm Pacific Time, there are usually about a dozen posts, and of those, more of them seem to be Smallville than SPN.

And then I always think, damn, I could have clicked and read, because no one was talking SPN at all!

I very much wouldn't call the Lost and VM threads "failed" -- they've played out their lifecycle, or are on course to do it. They've served a very useful purpose to members of this community and are still doing so.

If we did split out Broadcast and Cable shows, would the split be like:

Broadcast -Supernatural -Smallville -Heroes -(Lost?)

Cable -Dr. Who -Stargate(s) -Eureka -Dresden Files -Battlestar Galactica -(Torchwood, if it ever comes to America)

Am I missing any currently discussed shows?

We talk about Life on Mars in there occasionally.

(Note that if this were the Theodistas Board, we'd definitely have a Dirty Jobs thread.)

Does anybody have a unique-word-counter program available? If we fed in the text of the current Boxed Set thread, I bet the Top 100 Words would include Heroes, Supernatural, Dean, Sam, Winchester, Cheerleader, Hiro, Haitian, Stargate.

And Jack. We probably should just have a Jack thread, for shows that have Jacks in them.

I would be quite startled to see Haitian and Cheerleader up there.

Well the problem for me with the Heroes is that I want to watch it but probably won't have time until (I assume) it comes out on DVD before the 2nd season. So I have to skim Boxed Set like mad to find BSG discussion and stay as unspoiled as possible for Heroes (which I haven't really succeeded in doing). It wouldn't bother me at all to skip by Heroes discussion in the thread if I just didn't care for or about Heroes.

This is exactly my problem. I'm dying to read & post about BSG, but I haven't had time to watch Heroes this season. I fully intend to buy it on DVD as soon as it comes out, so I really don't want to be spoiled on it. I made the mistake of going in Boxed Set in a couple of months ago because I was giddy about BSG and was inadvertently spoiled for a big character plot point in Heroes. I haven't been back since. I know that we can't have a thread for every show, but taking Heroes out of Boxed Set would make a huge difference for me personally.

It's the overlap that bothers me, as well as the possibility of being spoiled for something I'm timeshifting. Do people feel that talk about Heroes and Supernatural crowds out talk about other shows? I don't like to interrupt a conversation about one show to yak about another; lots of people are talking about the BSG episode in progress when I want to talk about TDF after the episode ends, so I don't talk about it as much as I'd like to. Maybe others feel that way about SPN and/or Heroes?

Isn't there as much talk about Supernatural and BSG as there is about Heroes? I understand not wanting to create a bajillion new threads - or even three - but isn't there precedent for giving a show its own thread when it generates a storm of posts? That's what led to the creation of the Lost and Veronica Mars threads, right? And if those two threads seem to be winding down now (I don't watch them, so I don't really know how many posts there are about them), perhaps they could be re-absorbed into Boxed Set and replaced with SPN and Heroes threads.

And if BSG is really going on a nearly year-long hiatus soon, well, that solves that, at least for now.

eta there were lots of posts while I was writing this.