SPN certainly gets a lot of traffic. No doubt Eureka will when we get new episodes again.

If the thread is Thursday starts SPN flurry of posts and Monday starts flurry of Heroes posts will people not want to inject their SPN discussion on Tuesday.

Then Torchwood or Who will start up again. Whee!

Maybe marking the beginning of posts with a show tag would help.

people not want to inject their SPN discussion on Tuesday

If people don't want to, the thread is broken.

As someone who has watched BSG and Heroes but not yet this week's Dresden Files, I did notice DF conversation popping up after both other shows aired. Do people feel hesitant?

Boxed Set is getting confusing with the number of shows being discussed.

Yeah, this is my main concern. There are a lot of shows being discussed right now. I admit it is mitigated somewhat by the way the shows are spread out through the week, i.e., Heroes on Monday, SPN on Thursday, Dresden and BSG on Sunday.

eta: Maybe I'll just let Laura make my points...

Well the problem for me with the Heroes is that I want to watch it but probably won't have time until (I assume) it comes out on DVD before the 2nd season. So I have to skim Boxed Set like mad to find BSG discussion and stay as unspoiled as possible for Heroes (which I haven't really succeeded in doing). It wouldn't bother me at all to skip by Heroes discussion in the thread if I just didn't care for or about Heroes.

It wouldn't bother me at all to skip by Heroes discussion in the thread if I just didn't care for or about Heroes.

I know this is a proposal about Heroes and not any of the other shows that generate discussion, but for me it's important to know if Heroes is typical or atypical as this decision is made.

I am still anti-proliferation, despite our relative freedom on this dedicated server. Currently all the posts are kept in one table, and since we haven't been purging threads (which I consider a good thing, since searching archived threads can be a bother), the table's pretty big right now.

John H had a good idea (I think it was him) about splitting each thread into its own table. That would give us more breathing room (though each change only has limited breathing room to explore) for multiple threads. Not that it's on the to-do list anywhere but in my head.

So I'm still the same girl I used to be, just for different precise reasons, same general ones.

I think Heroes gets a lot of discussion, and it tends to be intricate and detail-oriented, full of debates about minutiae and implications. It's also a highly-rated show that's definitely been renewed; with its own thread, it might become a draw for new users.

I haven't found that it completely screws up the conversations around it due to its 900-lb-gorilla-ness, but then, I'm usually part of those conversations.

(I don't want to completely denude Boxed Set, which is why I'm a little hesitant. If we strip Heroes, and then possibly Supernatural, out of Boxed Set, then we're back down to 2-3 Sci Fi Channel shows in that thread, plus all the dead/British/ahemmed shows. Which isn't that much traffic, really.)

It may not be hesitance so much as gathering enough strength to carry on an extended discussion amongst several other conversations.

What crystallized my realization that a dedicated Heroes thread would be a good thing was Burrell's asking in Natter where to go to discuss it. I see the show drawing a large and broad enough variety of Buffistas to sustain a dedicated dialogue, not to mention activities like Watch 'N Posts.

I've no doubt that Boxed Set will have more than enough posting on the many remaining shows to more than sustain itself. It's a non-zero-sum game situation, wherein we'll enhance the community by having a new show discussion added, making it easier to find the discussion, as well as those people who want to avoid it will have that many fewer posts to wade through.

It crystallised for you for Heroes, but not for Eureka. What was the difference for you there?

Just a reminder of how this voting thing works, since it\'s been six months:

Four days of discussion followed by three days of voting. Theo will need to come up with final wording by early Sunday, at which time I\'ll open the \"ballot box\". We\'ll need a volunteer to count votes. Voting will end next Wednesday morning.

Adding a thread for heroes will have exactly zero measurable effect on server performance.

Worries about server performance should not factor into anyone's decision on whether to add a thread for Heroes or not.