Ok, let's talk history. This is not the first time that Doctor Who has done this plot. (Specifically, the final part – a powerful entity who is trapped alone inside another universe, which they can shape as they please; seeks to have the Doctor stay to keep them company forever.) But it was very different. For this we go back to the Third Doctor, and the show's tenth anniversary.
Patrick Troughton as the Second Doctor was charismatic and talented; but the scriptwriters were running out of ideas. (e.g. in season 5, all but one adventure was a variation on the base under siege setting.) When he decided to leave after three years, ratings were poor, and the show faced cancellation. In fact, the only reason it wasn't was because production of the new show they tapped to replace it ran into trouble. The BBC agreed to one more year while they teed up another option. The showrunners decided this called for drastic action, and they basically blew up the whole premise of Doctor Who. Jon Pertwee's Third Doctor was going to be an Avengers-style action man. All of time and space was shelved; the time Lords stranded him on Earth with a broken TARDIS. The scruffy anarchist who brought down governments instead joined a shadowy military organisation and became a staunch defender of the status quo.
It was hugely popular with audiences, especially once they added Jo Grant as his companion and the Master as his nemesis, and the show was reprieved. It was less popular with the new showrunners, who chafed at being restricted to present-day Earth. (There's a story that one writer complained the only options for Earth stories were mad scientist or alien invasion. The script editor, Terrance Dicks, responded by coming up with the Silurians, a now-displaced native race that had been masters of the planet before us. So, three options.)
After three seasons they were ready to do something about it. This was also the show's tenth year on the air, and they resolved to open with some event television, the show's first (unless you count the Christmas episode in The Daleks' Master Plan). Back came the Time Lords, a figure from Gallifrey's past, the universe in peril, but the big draw was right there in the adventure's title: The Three Doctors. They brought back William Hartnell and Patrick Troughton to reprise their roles. They found regeneration's second trick: for the first time, three Doctors would share the stage.
Or that was the plan at least. Even when in the role, Hartnell's health had been failing (a large part of why he was replaced). By now, he was simply too unwell to do so. he still appears - on the TARDIS' monitor, propped up in a chair and reading advice from cue cards. (As a child, of course, I noticed none of this.) He still steals the show when he's on screen (so to speak). It was Hartnell's last acting role of any kind before his death two years later. He'd been the Doctor for 137 episodes of the show.
That left Pertwee and Troughton to handle the action. That was prickly - Pertwee felt threatened having Troughton back, and was frustrated with Troughton's habit of ad libbing lines. (Troughton was much more the experienced actor; Pertwee's background was in light entertainment.) But eventually they sorted it out, with I think a bit of ego-stroking.
On to the plot, and hopefully the semblance of an actual point. In the story, the Time Lords' energy is being drained through a black hole, while alien creatures are beamed from it to seek the Doctor. The desperate Time Lords break the First Law of Time to unite the Doctor with his past incarnations to fight the threat. It turns out to be the work of Omega, a legendary figure from Gallifrey's past. It was he who engineered the energy source for the Time Lords' time travel (working with Rassilon), but he got caught in the gears, so to speak, and trapped in an anti-matter universe. Now he seeks revenge on the Time Lords who he feels abandoned him, and wants the Doctor to take his place – to sustain the anti-matter universe so he can return to ours. Once he discovers that his body has faded away, leaving only his will (and he is thus unable to leave), he instead demands the Doctor(s) remain to keep him company for eternity. The Doctors defeat him when they discover the Second Doctor's recorder had fallen into the TARDIS' inner workings. When they'd all crossed over, Omega was able to basically convert them to anti-matter, preventing an explosion. But the recorder, caught in temporal stasis, was not converted. They trick him into removing it from its stasis field and scarper in the TARDIS as the pocket universe explodes. The grateful Time Lords lift the Doctor's exile, leaving him free once again to roam the universe in his big blue box.
So there are some obvious parallels with It Takes You Away. What interests me are the differences. Omega is partly a tragic figure, but also clearly a megalomaniac, a danger and an enemy. The only appropriate response is to defeat him. Some dialogue, as he wallows in self-pity for his imprisonment:
The Doctor: "All my life I've known of you and honoured you as our greatest hero."
Omega: "A hero? I should have been a god!"
Captain Logic is not driving his tugboat. But 40 years later, that's no longer good enough. The Solitract isn't evil. Defeating it isn't a matter of overpowering it, not even of tricking it; in fact, the idea that the Doctor is tricking it is explicitly rejected. Rather, it's about finding the right emotional response. It's an adversary of sorts, but it's not hostile. The entire tone of that part of the story is worlds away from the Third Doctor's era. It's much lower key, lower stakes, but greater emotional complexity.
One of the reasons I love this show is that the Doctor wins through cleverness before violence. Overall, you'd have to say it's got better at that over time.
The Doctor Who finale: well, that was unquestionably a thing that happened. Chibnall has definitely created no less than fifty minutes of television right there.
Chibnall has definitely created no less than fifty minutes of television right there.
I kind of feel that way about this entire season? But the ratings have been great, so I guess this is the kind of thing most people want Doctor Who to be doing?
It's been a good season for former Downton Abbey ladies maids though.
I kind of feel that way about this entire season? But the ratings have been great, so I guess this is the kind of thing most people want Doctor Who to be doing?
This season's decent ratings are both heartening and dispiriting. Overall I liked the eps not written by Chibnall - even when they were messes, they were interesting messes. His stuff was just... dull. Falls somewhere between unambitious and morally incoherent.
Oh, by the way, concerning (apparently? I think that's the intention?) the season's big villain, this is what Tim Shaw means to Australians: [link]
But wait, there's more! [link]
But I know you want more! [link]
Because I am behind on everything I have only seen the 1st episode of Doctor Who this season. I only hope the watching is as interesting as reading billytea's commentary has been!
I am heartened by the ratings because I was really worried (from BTS gossip about what a disaster Chibnall was as showrunner) that the show wouldn't do well this year and the BBC leadership would go "Well I guess we shouldn't have made the Doctor a lady!" So in that sense, YAY.
But in another sense, NOT YAY because BLEARGH, Auntie Beeb, please make the show better next year do not take these numbers as a cue to keep making boring television.
I am heartened by the ratings because I was really worried (from BTS gossip about what a disaster Chibnall was as showrunner) that the show wouldn't do well this year and the BBC leadership would go "Well I guess we shouldn't have made the Doctor a lady!" So in that sense, YAY.
But in another sense, NOT YAY because BLEARGH, Auntie Beeb, please make the show better next year do not take these numbers as a cue to keep making boring television.
I am in total agreement with all of this! There are rumours that Chris Chibnall is only going to stick around for one more season, and I kind of hope that's true. (Though I don't know who might be available to take it on.)
