But when it came down to cookies v. cake, I would say that in most instances I'd prefer a cookie, but had to admit that a great slice of cake was better than the best cookie.

For me it all depends on the cake and the cookie. If I'm not careful I can binge out on Samoas or double-stuff Oreos, but most packaged or even good bakery cookies aren't to my taste. Too sweet, too dense. But a crisp, homemade cookie where there's enough butter, salt, and/or flavor to balance out the sweetness is bliss. Likewise with cakes I don't like them when they're too sweet, which most of them are.

But what about cake vs. pie? When I was younger I was on Team Cake, but now I'm Team Pie all the way. Pecan pies in the winter, strawberry or blackberry in the summer...mmm....

But what about cake vs. pie? When I was younger I was on Team Cake, but now I'm Team Pie all the way. Pecan pies in the winter, strawberry or blackberry in the summer...mmm....

Tricky one. It's all in the details, right?

Mr. Flea made me and Emmett some of the best pies I've had. So when you're alive to the fruit and the tart and the balance of sweetness and a perfect crust you've got something special.

But the place I go to for Matilda's bday cakes specializes in old school Austrian style cake making. Not too far from what you see on the Great British Bakeoff. But that was revelatory to get away from the dominance of buttercream frostings in America and sample cakes with whipped cream and mousse between the layers. Those can be exquisite and complex.

today's news has just set my head of fire.

So I will think about cake instead. Maybe I will bake one tomorrow

Good cake is excellent, as are good cookies, but I want to put in a word for mousse or creme brûlée--deliciousness you eat up with a spoon.

Good cake is really good and runs about even with good pie for me. But given a choice between mid-rate cake and mid-rate pie, I'll choose pie every time. Mid-rate deserts tend to substitute sweetness for flavor, and mid-rate cakes tend to be dry as well.

Scrappy reminds me -- did I ever post here about the chocolate mousse I made with aquafaba? Has anyone else used it? It's frigging magic!

I prefer making pies, but I like eating cakes.

Aquafaba!!! I haven't used it but my gf vegan friend was obsessed with it for a while so we talked about it a lot.

Pie! I can pass up cake easily, and cookies, but pie is the bestest.

I have to keep off FB today, if I can. My rage level is way over the top. Eye is twitching. I don't think more coffee is going to help either, but that is where I am headed now.

It depends on the specifics of the pie or the cake for me. Given a choice of all desserts, I'd probably pick ice cream first.

I'm done with winter and would like it to go away now please. It's messing with my week and my pain levels.