I thought it had its moments of creepiness, and I liked that there was actually a developing story behind the haunting.
Spielberg's ending is way scarier than the original.
A place to talk about movies--old and new, good and bad, high art and high cheese. It's the place to place your kittens on the award winners, gossip about upcoming fims and discuss DVD releases and extras. Spoiler policy: White font all plot-related discussion until a movie's been in wide release two weeks, and keep the major HSQ in white font until two weeks after the video/DVD release.
I thought it had its moments of creepiness, and I liked that there was actually a developing story behind the haunting.
Spielberg's ending is way scarier than the original.
Nothing nothing nothing has ever quite spooked me as much as "I can feel it breathing on me." ::whoosh:: Yeah, it's scariness is a creepy scary, but it was very effective on me. The J-horror-esqe stepping out of bed to stand catatonic was powerful. S used to do things like that in the night, albiet for entirely different reasons. And I agree that Speilberg's ending was far superior, I would have been interested to see some combination of the two - Katie getting out of bed to stand over Micah (that was SUPER creepy), going downstairs, we hear the horrible scream from Speilberg's ending, she thumps back up, throws Micah into the camera, crawls in animal-like, and then slits her own throat for the camera, smiling a demon smile.
But really just to see how that idea would play
I don't know whose ending I saw.
In the original ending, Katie gets out of bed, stands catatonic for a bit, goes downstairs, screams, Micah runs downstairs, we hear more screaming, Katie comes back up with the kitchen knife and slits he own throat for the camera.
In Speilberg's ending, Katie gets out of bed, stands over Micah, goes downstairs, scream, Micah rushes down, screams, thumping back up the stairs, Micah's gets thrown into the camera, Katie crawls in all animal-like, turns demon-face, cut to a title saying Micah's body was found, Katie's whereabouts are unknown.
Sean, I think that combination would have been neat too. Because the scariest part of Spielberg's ending was her throwing Micah at the camera. The demon lunge at the camera was just sort of standard.
javachik, I'm pretty sure theatres only showed Spielberg's ending, which I basically described above. The original ending had Katie walking back to the bedroom, presumably having killed Micah downstairs, and slitting her throat in front of the camera. The director's cut apparently has a third ending that just sounds weird where Katie stands in front of the camera for DAYS until the cops show up, and she goes down and gets shot by them or something.
Weird. I saw that third ending. I didn't even know about the other two.
Thanks! I might have actually preferred the original ending. But I did enjoy the movie a lot.
More than anything, it was the actors that sold me. Superb performances. Especially Katie.
Reading everyone's white font has convinced me that I NEVER NEED TO SEE this movie. Ever. It is the type of creepy movie that will freak me out FAR too effectively.
Especially Katie.
She went to SMU!