It's my estimation that... every man ever got a statue made of him, was one kind of sumbitch or another.

Mal ,'Jaynestown'


Supernatural 2: Why is it our job to save everybody?  

[NAFDA]. This is where we talk about the CW series Supernatural! Anything that's aired in the US on TV (including promos) is fair game. No spoilers though — if you post one by accident, an admin will delete it.


§ ita § - Mar 19, 2012 4:06:43 pm PDT #24570 of 30002
Well not canonically, no, but this is transformative fiction.

Oy, people.

"I would also imagine that Jared and Jensen are a bit tired of these roles"

"No, that's not what they say"

"Well, of course they'd come back if offered the right package"

"NO THAT'S NOT WHAT THEY SAY"

Why can't you just leave it at that? That interviews and con appearances contradict you? Actors "need" this, Jensen and Jared "are" that. Enh, all we know is what they say. That's all. *You* are the one that's tired of the show. And you're uber-projecting.


§ ita § - Mar 19, 2012 5:20:16 pm PDT #24571 of 30002
Well not canonically, no, but this is transformative fiction.

Some people on IO9 are suggesting that the cancer George mentioned was metaphorical (referring to humans), and others are saying that they need to cure cancer because they can't eat cancerous people (and someone suggested Frank has cancer, so he'll be okay). So far only one person has suggested that Dick wants to cure cancer because it will make him look good and then he can be president.

Any opinions?

I'm honestly flummoxed. A little disturbed by the idea that cancer might be the key to defeating them, but I really don't want a big cancer plotline right now. I'm in a delicate headspace.


sumi - Mar 19, 2012 5:21:35 pm PDT #24572 of 30002
Art Crawl!!!

I really thought that Dick may have told underlings one thing but who knows what he is really up to.


Amy - Mar 19, 2012 5:25:23 pm PDT #24573 of 30002
Because books.

I don't really think they're curing cancer, even for their own benefit.

I also don't think the writers would set up that plotline -- cancer isn't a joke, and having murderous, oil slick creatures curing it when scientists have been trying for years? Not funny, but also not good horror.

So far only one person has suggested that Dick wants to cure cancer because it will make him look good and then he can be president.

I guess I could kind of see this, but I hope they don't do that.


§ ita § - Mar 19, 2012 5:45:18 pm PDT #24574 of 30002
Well not canonically, no, but this is transformative fiction.

I think it can be effective horror. I've read cancer-fixated stories that worked well. Octavia Butler's brilliant Xenogenesis stories had cancer-obsessed aliens, if memory serves. It was something about the human potential for cancer that fascinated the aliens, and that's why they wanted to breed with us.

The reasons I don't want to see it are entirely personal. I do think it can be done well.

I don't think we'd have been given a mislead at this point, though, sumi--it's too late, and it's too random, and I do think that whatever they want, it's not like what we've been trained to expect, because of the 30 year thing. So curing disease fits with that.

The question is--is it curing disease in the To Serve Man fashion, or is it some sort of perverted do-gooding, like they'll also fix the energy crisis, etc? I mean, they're clearly doing everything everywhere, and this is the first time we've seen monsters play with human toys. They're not looking for mystical weapons or spells or opening portals or doing anything supernatural. They're playing the human game, and they're playing it better than humans do.

That's why something like disease makes sense to me. It still very mundane.


Amy - Mar 19, 2012 5:52:36 pm PDT #24575 of 30002
Because books.

I'd have to see it played out, I guess. I took as George fucking with them, or what sumi suggested -- repeating what Dick had told them. I've never seen it done, and it doesn't sound promising to me, but that's just me.


Juliebird - Mar 19, 2012 5:58:51 pm PDT #24576 of 30002
I am the fly who dreams of the spider

I'd almost prefer it to be cancer in the Matrix way of "Humans are a disease, and we are the cure" but then they'd have nothing left to eat.

And if they're taking over the globe that fast and invasive, that was a fuckton of Leviathans inside Cas. What's the occupancy of the Chrysler building? Can they breed?


§ ita § - Mar 19, 2012 6:08:50 pm PDT #24577 of 30002
Well not canonically, no, but this is transformative fiction.

And if they're taking over the globe that fast and invasive

How many do you estimate they are? I figure the capacity was effectively infinite, since it seemed to be ooze, but I don't get the impression that there are necessarily more leviathans than there could be demons loosed from hell or anything. It feels like there are a couple people in most sizable population centres. Which is a lot, but...I dunno. It doesn't feel fucktonnish to me.

I'd have to see it played out, I guess. I took as George fucking with them, or what sumi suggested -- repeating what Dick had told them

On a meta level, I just don't think there's any room for that in the back half. I think it could be misleading, maybe even tangential, but not plain wrong. We don't have time. Not with Sam's breakdown and the probable also inclusion of monsters of the week in the remaining seven eps.


Strix - Mar 19, 2012 6:16:20 pm PDT #24578 of 30002
A dress should be tight enough to show you're a woman but loose enough to flee from zombies. — Ginger

I just hope it's not at the end of the episode.

Oh, that's the first thing I said to D Friday after ep was "You know he'll show up in the last 30 seconds next week."

I was still irritated that I thought I'd lost a week.

I don't have a good theory; I got NOTHING from the preview that ties into Dick's motivation. The most logical ideas to me seem to be either "humans are the cancer" or "if we have to live on earth, we're all going to have lots of money and extra humans to eat" but there are huge logic holes in both.

I am very curious for Friday.


§ ita § - Mar 19, 2012 6:21:42 pm PDT #24579 of 30002
Well not canonically, no, but this is transformative fiction.

"You know he'll show up in the last 30 seconds next week."

Their promo people haven't done that to us before, that I recall. I don't have any strong reason to expect they'll start now.