Her Dean-as-janitor one sure surprised me!

Now I'm all aflutter in anticipation. I only read the prisoner/doctor one so far: hawt. Also, hope Dean's lying about killing his whole family. Makes me sad.

Yeah, Matt, the Angel's would all have to be old and grey-haired to be in keeping with their canon selves maturity and experience. I think I've just gotten used to author's using Speight's actual age as a reference for AU!Gabriel.

I'm mostly used to them using the relative authorities of the angels to determine their ages, starting with Castiel being about Dean's age. Which tends to leave an awkward gap for S/G if it's a high school story.

I don't quite see a way out of the prisoner/doctor one if the truth has been told so far. So I'm assuming there's more to it than that.

She also has to finish the story about gay camp. I think author's notes should mention when Sam and Dean aren't related, especially when there's a reverse age difference. I spent way too long trying to make that work.

Of course, he's not a horse, as I suspect was done in the Tangled adaptation. Which irritated me, because Cas was the babiest specialest angel again. But I guess there needed to be a reason for him to be locked up in a tower.

what with them being hundreds of millions of years older than the Winchesters in canon.

"Why can't I date an eight billion year old nebulous form wearing a tax accountant? He's a good 'guy' and heeeee didn't step on the little fish that would evolve into an amphibian."

I think I am just about done with fic fanon having Dean making huge life decisions to pay for Sam's higher education (entering into risky, shady, dangerous situations and lifestyles, working twenty jobs, giving up his own dreams, etc).

People, Sam made his own way! Why is fic!Sam suddenly incompetent (I know that's not the motive behind it, but I always get a little mad at lazy lazy Sam when I read it)? Why do the writers think Dean needs this? I can see it being shorthand for how self-sacrificing Dean is for Sam, but, like, isn't just practically raising the kid good enough? Is it to make up for the lack of Dean getting a chance to trade his soul for Sam's life in this type of fic? (this actually makes sense to me, but I wish writers found other creative ways to replace that pivotal gesture instead of adopting this as fact). Is this a D/C failing, or does it pop up in gen and wincest AU's?

In related news, am very excited over the D/C western to come out of the BB.

I don't mind the idea that Dean thinks his shot at a vaguely normal life is less important than a very good shot for Sam. Sam obviously has to do some work--he's putting in the study hours. Dean's just making sure he has the luxury of living with his head in the books, while Dean puts food on the table, etc, for him. I don't get the impression that Sam is lazy, just that he's working his ass off academically, and in more than a few stories the happy ending is when he gets a full ride and Dean gets to ease up on what ever he's doing.

I think, for me, it's that it has entered the territory of "Castiel is a weird name"/"My parents were very religious" and "Sam's bitchface number eleven".

Unlike those, I think it's integral to his character, the giving up and lack of a desire to do things for himself.

Dean will reward himself (fulfill his desires) in only the smallest and most fleeting ways possible -- getting laid, a piece of pie, a steam shower. That's his bliss.

I don't quite understand getting mad at the Sam (or whatever character) in the story, though. If anything, I would be annoyed at the author if I thought they were writing something really OOC, or making one character unattractive without good reason.