ita, do I have to forsake you twice? /crack addict

FWIW, I'm not interested in fic, I'm interested in SPN fic. But if rules is rules is rules, I'll abide by that.

If we move this volume of fic talk over there, specific fics and shit, if it's enough to overwhelm one of the highest volume threads on the board, what do you think it's going to do to the existing fic thread?

Rules are rules. If fic is deemed off topic here, then I won't talk about it here. But I'm not going to participate in radically changing the thread culture of a different thread. You guys want to change this thread, let's change this thread.

However I think it's inconsistent to leave vids and fanart on the table and exclude fic.

Oh now I get what you're saying. From my perspective, I feel like more traffic is good for any thread, but I can understand how it might be disconcerting for a thread you're used to being a certain way suddenly becoming very different.

I'm lost. I'm not being twee or deliberately obtuse, I really don't get it, because I thought the fic threads were for discussing and rec'ing fic. Is that wrong? Are there some kind of special cooties on SPN fic that can't mix with fic from other fandoms? It was my understanding that the fic rec and fic writing threads were created back in the mists of time because some people in Bitches found fic talk tiresome. And it's also my impression that SPN was removed from Boxed Set not because the discussion was at odds with the purpose of BS, but because the volume of SPN discussion was consistently overcoming discussion of other shows.

It just seems to me--unless there's some stigma to SPN fic that other fandoms'fic doesn't have that I don't know about--that the fic threads are there for fic discussion.

Am I wrong?

Of course, I don't want to inhibit the way anyone else enjoys the show or the thread, so if the desire is strong for fic discussion to stay here, then so be it. Recs, whether of writing, art, or any other fan generated material, should of course stay here.

I enjoy BTS and actor gossip. I would think that belongs here, unless someone objects to that.

ETA: Sorry, I hadn't seen ita's post.

There have been SPN fic recs in the fic thread. There's been some discussion of SPN fic there. Which honestly was why I was puzzled when that discussion moved over here. I see now that ita's objection to "invading" the fic thread is due to possible volume and overwhelm rather than purpose, so I don't know what that outcome would be. The thread is dormant as it is, so conflict would appear to be nonexistant.

But if people are uncomfortable talking about a specific show anywhere other than the show-labeled thread, I think the best solution is to just leave things as they are.

I was frustrated by something, I knew other people were frustrated, I offered a suggestion. I did not mean for it to be taken as a demand. The original fic thread was created in the first place because the same thing happened with Buffy, so I thought it was a reasonable suggestion.

I can understand how it might be disconcerting for a thread you're used to being a certain way suddenly becoming very different

And that right there is part of my issue. I feel--and it's a feeling, so please don't quote stats at me--that fic discussion has taken over here in a way that it hasn't previously, and I was voicing my frustration. No doubt things will go back to what I consider 'normal' once Show starts again.

Of course, I don't want to inhibit the way anyone else enjoys the show or the thread, so if the desire is strong for fic discussion to stay here, then so be it. Recs, whether of writing, art, or any other fan generated material, should of course stay here.

Or, what Beverly said.

BTS?

Are there some kind of special cooties on SPN fic that can't mix with fic from other fandoms?

It's possible I'm still just raw from the expulsion of SPN from Boxed Set, but I've tried to talk SPN fic in there before, and ... crickets. It has an established culture, and SPN has never gained traction. I don't feel it's my place to charge in with a group of people and disturb that.

Now, y'all can, if you want. I just don't want to.

Wait--leave recs here and discussion there? That's even more confusing for me.

the volume of SPN discussion was consistently overcoming discussion of other shows.

Isn't that just what would happen in the fic thread?

that fic discussion has taken over here in a way that it hasn't previously, and I was voicing my frustration.

While the show is on air?

Also, Anne, I'm not seeing it as a demand. I'm seeing discussion of the right move to make.

I think what people are saying is that we talk about SPN fic a lot and if that talk were to move to the very low traffic Fic thread, suddenly it would seem like all SPN all the time and that might overwhelm users who are used to Fic being about all kinds of fan fiction.

I don't feel like we talk about about fic too much here while the show is running. There's bursts of activity, but I've never had trouble finding show discussion. But that's just my experience and as I said, I'm happy to have the SPN fic talk in here.