I've seen some of those discussions on-line about how reprehensible it was for Dean to have Death re-soul Sam and I just don't get it. If keeping RoboSam soulless means that essence of Sam stays trapped in the cage while a vessel walks around wearing his face and doing things that are at morally questionable (at best), wouldn't that essentially be the same as Dean letting Sam remain possessed? I don't really see the difference between re-inserting a soul over the objections of the vessel and exorcising a demon over the objections of the demon.

Or maybe it's just me that's wallowing in Dean's pain.

I don't really see the difference between re-inserting a soul over the objections of the vessel and exorcising a demon over the objections of the demon.

I don't think they defined terms very well, sadly. Sam seems to be able to remember his life, just not how he felt about it, or the ability to *feel* at all. Which doesn't make a lot of sense to me, same as the not sleeping issue. What does that have to do with a soul?

They did it better on Buffy, making the soul strictly the essence of someone's goodness, to whatever degree. At least for me, it was a little more cut and dried that way.

Does "enjoying be malicious and cruel" fall under "feelings"? Because it seems to be like it does.

I've seen some of those discussions on-line about how reprehensible it was for Dean to have Death re-soul Sam

I thought the writers were specifically trying to address this point by having Sam try to kill Bobby. It seems to me that any "person" who makes this choice needs to be resouled by any means necessary.

You are really fucked up if you think this is a viable solution to your problems.

Does "enjoying be malicious and cruel" fall under "feelings"? Because it seems to be like it does.

Yeah! Which is also inconsistent. He still knows how to laugh at things and how to flirt, and has no filter when it comes to cruelness.

Which sounds more like pure id than a lack of feeling, but they've made it clear he *can't* feel concern or love or whatever, and it doesn't make a lot of sense.

So I say, resoul the boy! Let's have some good old-fashioned Sammy angst.

I don't know if he's a *wallower,* though. To me that means seeking out pain, and I think if there wasn't any that directly affected him or his loved ones, he wouldn't seek it.

Wallowing doesn't imply seeking for me, but it does involve rolling around in what's there. Dean? Will sit in the dark and feel until the cows come home. I mean, he'll also do, but he'll generate those perfect single manly tears of pain from his internal landscape all day long.

Well, yeah, he does like to roll around in what's there. Bless his little wounded heart.

Earn your fan status, people.

I want to marry this sentence.

someone on io9 was spewing pure hate about Ackles in the last post, I think. Disparaging his acting

This is in the other universe, right? The one without shrimp? Nonsense in this one and I am SO glad ita put the smack down on that ridiculousness.

DitW is a must-see on my list.

Damn, there are so many good episodes in the past.

I mean, he'll also do, but he'll generate those perfect single manly tears of pain from his internal landscape all day long.

It's about time for another one. I've missed them.

Is it just angels that taste of cinnamon and summer and winter and seabreeze and other random things that, you know, people don't go around tasting like, or do they write that crap into more general porn?

Because Dean may always smell like leather and salt and gun oil, and Sam smells like that girly shampoo (you can tell which way my fic is biased), but at least they don't usually taste freakish.