Either do I, but I think he did a bunch of work which effected viewpoints and spoke out about a bunch of issues and I think he deserves kudos for that.
I think, Kevin, as seems to happen on some occasions, you are missing the greater point people are trying to make. I don't really think that just because Joss says, "I love women! I'm totally feminist! I'm almost a woman myself because I'm so sensitive! My sexist show is really feminist because I AM!" makes it so.
Just because he also says he's so gay doesn't actually make him gay or even kinda gay.
I actually find the self-declarative labels as an explanation for things which are offensive really annoying.
I actually find the self-declarative labels as an explanation for things which are offensive really annoying.
You mean, "It's okay, because I'm a FEMINIST! Really!" ?
'Cause I am right there with you.
Thanks, Steph.
Also, being a feminist isn't a contest. And just because someone thinks Tim does a better job writing authentic-ish female characters than Joss doesn't mean that Joss is being dissed.
I actually find the self-declarative labels as an explanation for things which are offensive really annoying.
It is pretty much the same as predicating a statement with "I'm no rascist, but...", or "I don't mean to be offensive, but...", isn't it?
Not just annoying but painfully cringe-inducing from someone who you have respected at some point.
*sigh*
For the record, I do still respect a lot of what Joss has done, even with Dollhouse, but it's getting more difficult. And I suspect that others are past the point of no return.
OTOH, where the series left off has a lot of potential, and a multitude of ways to leave the more problematic aspects behind.
for some reason, this discussion is reminding of discussions of "nice guys." To wit,
[link]
Ugh, yeah. "Nice Guys"? Not that nice.
for some reason, this discussion is reminding of discussions of "nice guys."
Yeppers. Where "for some reason" = "because it's exactly the same tired self-congratulatory vibe".
On a less imflamatory level, it's like insisting out loud how cool and hip you are. If you have to announce it...
Also, being a feminist isn't a contest.
Ding ding ding! Yes.
Or, as they say in the biz, show, don't tell.
On a less imflamatory level, it's like insisting out loud how cool and hip you are. If you have to announce it...
I am mostly cloudy, 59 °F, and I have two hips.