He basically seemed to be the Ringers guy.

I hate "I am irrationally jealous of your perfectly above board interaction with a guy whose crime is being cuter than me" -> "Oh, well, there was a kiss, so my caveman possessiveness was totally founded, except not founded, because there was no EVIDENCE..."

That is one of the "new we've gotten them together" things I'd love to avoid. Never mind Moonlighting. THIS.

However, I'm sure I'll find out that it not only happens in real life, but it's also exciting when it does, so it's both plausible and entertaining. Enh.

Agree. But I'm not real wild about the flirty intimate conversation leading to that kiss either.

Is there something vaguely different about Ioan Gruffudd's face?

I think it's just the distinct lack of pocket squares.

I did like the "why didn't you just push him away? Oh" bit, but, yeah, not my favorite cliche.

If Tiva kiss this episode, they might have a more charged ship than Destiel, but only might. Jeez, I forget the writers even pretended they were a thing...

Elementary: daaaaaaamn, Jonny Lee Miller. Talking about his sobriety anniversary? Blew. Me. Away.

I was, to put it mildly, unimpressed by Joan's gift.

I desperately wanted it to be a deerstalker hat.

I wanted it to be anything but a badly calligraphed, badly framed lame quote.

I wanted Holmes to make a Charles Bronson joke in dismissal.

I didn't find the quote lame at all. I love Robert Frost.

Neat twist, in the story, Milverton's death is the climax, not the crux of the mystery.