Juliebird - that scene you talk about really hurt, as it was supposed to. And I adored the moment when he realized no matter how horrible he felt, he couldn't destroy her illusions in either him or the story he'd constructed, and pulled it all back just a bit.

It didn't all work quite for me as well as I wish it had, mainly because I think the adventure doesn't really tie into either of their lives enough. However, I've only seen it once, and I know I missed that everyone in the story was played by someone who played someone in reality. Maybe it all ties in better than I caught the one time.

The more I watch it, (and I've watched it a lot in the past two months) the more I love it, and the more my quibbles with it disappear. And as much as I now love the thank you thank you thank you very much! ending, because of the sheer enthusiasm of the delivery by Catinca, it still feels so separate from the rest of the movie. And Roy's bouncing back from his Fall due to Alexandria's love doesn't seem to be addressed in any satisfactory way. But I really don't care, because I love everything else, even if it doesn't fit or doesn't make sense or doesn't pull together, because it was just such an incredibly enjoyable ride.

I'm glad you really liked the film because I really liked it too - very unexpectedly. I did not care for Tarsem's "The Cell" - so I watched this one on faith.

He is a very visual director who has a bit of trouble with narratives, but it seemed to come out on the other side okay with this movie. I think the vehicle of the storytelling worked well - given the movie references and that the whole thing wasn't supposed to be "real."

I watched every single one of the extras which actually made me like the film more.

Just got back from seeing Quantum of Solace. I have very few quibbles with the film. Daniel Craig rocks bond. Hard.

DH said I let out a noise when Bond said he hoped Fields had handcuffs. I had to admit I wibbled.

But damn, the action was so fast, it was almost hard to follow.

I did not care for Tarsem's "The Cell"

That's definitely a movie that is less than the sum of its parts, but there are some amazing parts there. Also, apart from "Out of Sight" (which I LOVE!), it's basically the only other movie I like J Lo in.

I *love* "Out of Sight." Man, that movie just hangs together so well and Clooney is the HOTTTT.

The scene in the trunk is every bit the show stopper it's supposed to be, but it's also so low key in it's way at the same time. Just brilliant acting and direction.

The looks on both their faces when she's in the apartment lobby and he's in the elevator...genius. Another grace note of brilliant acting and direction.

agreed. completely. and clooney's near wave.

I also saw QoS and must enthusiastically agree with the observation on Mr. Craig's hotness. Yowza. I agree that the action scenes were shot and cut ineffectively. I spent too mauch time going "Wait--what the-"