Ah. That could be.

But the only thing that leads me to believe otherwise is that Raylan seemed to acknowledge the indication of blame. Which I don't think he would accept if he were only the reason. But that's vague, I know.

She was careful to injure Coover's non-shooting hand and precise in inflicting damage, I don't think Dickie's limp is from Mags' punishment.

She was careful to injure Coover's non-shooting hand and precise in inflicting damage, I don't think Dickie's limp is from Mags' punishment.

Especially because she said something about if he wasn't already crippled to near-uselessness he'd be getting it too - hardly think she'd throw that out there if she had caused it.

I can't remember the details anymore either, but I definitely remember the limp being Raylan's fault as well.

I just did a Google search, and found this:

The setup is certainly intriguing: Davies plays “Dickie Bennett,” the smartest of three brothers and a high school rival of Givens. Since Prohibition, the Bennett and Givens families have warred like the Hatfields and McCoys. Dickie’s family traffics in weed, for which Bennett spent time in prison. He still walks with a limp due to an altercation with Raylan on the baseball field when they were both 17.

But that's the extent of it; I can't find any description of what the altercation was or why it resulted in a permanent limp.

They have not mentioned the backstory on the show.

Also, isn't the sheriff the smartest of the three?

Also, isn't the sheriff the smartest of the three?

That's certainly the impression I get.

eta: I might be willing to cop to Dickie having a higher IQ or something (I don't think we've been given the evidence one way or the other), but at the very least, Doyle's the one who's got more common sense...as evidenced by Dickie instigating all these incidents that were bound to Piss Off Mags, which we have been shown is not a wise course.

Dickie seems more sly, though. Doyle's not quite as Blunt Instrument as Coover, but I think without Mags keeping him in check, he wouldn't be where he is now. The impression I got was that Dickie would have been the alpha Bennett (the male alpha, anyway) if he hadn't been injured.

That's interesting...could very well be that the injury is what's keeping him from being the Alpha son...and with Mags talking to him like that, I wouldn't be surprised to see him pulling a Prince Jon/Iago/insert sly villain of your choice here...and maybe these moves that look like greedy dumbassery (especially with Coover there to make him look dumber) are actually testing the boundaries or making preliminary moves to set up something bigger down the road apiece...Veeery Interesting.

Re: Tonight's Justified -- Ooooh, I'm betting Raylan's going to get to shoot at least one bad guy by the end of the episode. (And he's been trying so hard to restrain himself!)