Flames wouldn't be eternal if they actually consumed anything.

Lilah ,'Not Fade Away'


Experimental TV: Comedy  

This thread is part of an experiment to determine Buffistas' interest in television discussion. It will close on June 1st, 2007, after which there will be a brief skirmish to sort out what we want to do next. This thread is for discussion of all comedy, regardless of airing station. [NAFDA]


esse - Apr 28, 2007 3:24:22 am PDT #176 of 447
S to the A -- using they/them pronouns!

The Office: JK's impressions are always quite good, and the Dwight impression--JK as Jim impersonating Dwight, even--was hilarious. I'd seen the opening bit on youtube before, but I didn't know there was a closing bit too. OMG the funny.

30 Rock: v. sad she and floyd are over. I thought that was both touching and funny and could have been extended longer. Loved Liz as Jack's emergency contact, adored Jack's mom, thought whatshisface from Will and Grace was his normal level of funny. The bit about hayseed and hillbilly was v. funny.

Scrubs: DAMN Keri Russell! a) I didn't know you could be hot in that way, but kudos to you for growing up to be a grade a hottie; b) who knew you could play tramp so well?

Yay for Elliot and her boytoy. They are very special.


bon bon - Apr 28, 2007 4:51:46 am PDT #177 of 447
It's five thousand for kissing, ten thousand for snuggling... End of list.

adored Jack's mom, thought whatshisface from Will and Grace was his normal level of funny. The bit about hayseed and hillbilly was v. funny.

Elaine Stritch! What great casting. She stole every scene. Sean Hayes, on the other hand...great idea in theory, nsm in execution.

I also loved the way they protrayed the breakdown of Floyd and Liz-- it felt truer than they usually get to.


esse - Apr 28, 2007 5:39:27 am PDT #178 of 447
S to the A -- using they/them pronouns!

Elain Stritch was brilliant. Absolutely brilliant. That gleam in her eye when she discovered a way to tell if Jack was lying to her? Genius.

The break-up was sad, but comedically sad. I think they shouldn't have written him out so quickly, but it definitely had that patina of frustration that long-distance relationships can accrue so fast. "Can we talk about something other than work?" that lead into the weather was just so sad, but also so true.


lisah - Apr 28, 2007 7:39:48 am PDT #179 of 447
Punishingly Intricate

Yay for Elliot and her boytoy. They are very special.

My tape totally cut off about mid-way through. What happened at the end?


esse - Apr 28, 2007 9:17:39 am PDT #180 of 447
S to the A -- using they/them pronouns!

After that really touching moment in the parking lot between JD and Elliot, they all went back to Elliot's house. The boytoy was supposed to be on a trip with his friends, but he was there when they got back; and it turned out that he had been seeing Elliot's dad to ask his permission to marry her. So he got down on one need and popped the ring out, Elliot looked stunned and happy, and JD bounded in media res with Keri Russell on his back.


lisah - Apr 28, 2007 10:12:02 am PDT #181 of 447
Punishingly Intricate

Thanks, SA!


Kevin - Apr 28, 2007 10:27:00 am PDT #182 of 447
Never fall in love with somebody you actually love.

I love The Office. Really.


Topic!Cindy - Apr 28, 2007 2:18:16 pm PDT #183 of 447
What is even happening?

lisah, my awakeness cut off, about halfway through.

Kevin, are you all caught up on season 3, now?


Topic!Cindy - Apr 29, 2007 1:05:23 am PDT #184 of 447
What is even happening?

I finally watched all of 30 Rock, and Scrubs.

If Alec Baldwin does leave 30 Rock, or the country, or whatever, I think they could make the show with Elaine Stritch, instead. She's wonderful. I'm glad Phoebe is gone. The character didn't work for me.

The break-up was sad, but comedically sad. I think they shouldn't have written him out so quickly, but it definitely had that patina of frustration that long-distance relationships can accrue so fast. "Can we talk about something other than work?" that lead into the weather was just so sad, but also so true.

Yes.

Scrubs was sweet. I also enjoyed Turk, Carla and Kelso having one over on Cox. I have a complaint about this season (and maybe last, I can't remember), though. Too much of the stuff that used to be clearly portrayed as happening in JD's head, now seems to actually happen to other characters, too. In this instance, it was the whatever-that-was with Elliot and the Keri Russell character, when they first ran into each other -- and squeed up a wind tunnel. Also, I wanted to see Carla do something about the Janitor ghosting pediatrics.


esse - Apr 29, 2007 2:11:08 am PDT #185 of 447
S to the A -- using they/them pronouns!

If Alec Baldwin does leave 30 Rock, or the country, or whateve

Sorry, I'm down on my celeb gossip--is that really a possibility? Because of that voicemail message or whatever?

something about the Janitor ghosting pediatrics.

oh, that was hilarious! in a horrific amusement way!