Top Design was bugging me a LOT. One, all of the challenges seemed completely arificial (rooms without windows of any kind, cabanas no person will ever used being judged on standards of practicality). It was really annoying to watch these idiotic challenges that could not possibly have been reflective of any kind of conditions they would ever face as designers in the real world.

Plus, in what seemed like a VERY subjective contest, the contestants were being judged by three people with the most startlingly atrocious taste in personal style. I would never take a criticism from any one of those people seriously. I'd laugh at them and point at his or her wardrobe and hair style.

I mean, all of these Bravo reality shows are subjective to one extent or another, but a hair one seems a little more concrete, they have judges with a personal style I can take seriously, and it seems difficult to come up with stupid and irrelevant challenges (which I felt basically everythin on Top Design was), though I'm sure they'll try.

Plus, Jaqueline Smith!

You know what I don't understand about the Top Design complaints? People who don't like Todd Oldham and/or Jonathan Adler. If anything, I just wanted MORE of those two crazy gays.

You know what I don't understand about the Top Design complaints? People who don't like Todd Oldham and/or Jonathan Adler. If anything, I just wanted MORE of those two crazy gays.

Seriously! I want Bravo's next TV show to be Tim Gunn, Tom Colicchio, and Jonathan Alder Sit Around A Table And Say Bitchy Things About People.

Todd Oldham is so sweet! I loved him. But he had far less of a role than, say, Tim Gunn on Runway. And he wasn't a judge like Chef Tom, so he was sort of useless, much as I like him. Jonathan Adler didn't bug me, but I hated Kelly Wearstler. Margaret just seemed snotty and elite.

The challenges were sort of blah, and there was no time to do the mini challenges like on Top Chef. Which I know they didn't do on Runway, either, but somehow it didn't matter.

Oh, I'd totally watch that show, Jess and Jesse.

I haven't been watching Shear Genius because the promos made it look unbelievably lame. (Not that that stopped me from watching Top Design, but I have to draw the line somewhere, right?)

I think you should give it a chance. I'm liking it much better than Top Design, plus.... horrible things done to people's heads!!!

Plus, in what seemed like a VERY subjective contest, the contestants were being judged by three people with the most startlingly atrocious taste in personal style. I would never take a criticism from any one of those people seriously. I'd laugh at them and point at his or her wardrobe and hair style.

AMEN. I could never take Kelly Wearstler seriously. I mean, remember the 80's prom dress over the tight jeans and stilletto heels? I had to gird my loins everytime she would first appear.

Also, the judges allowed their personal style and preferences to overly inform their decisions. I knew that Matt was going to win the finale because they would just like what he did better, because his aesthetic was in line with their own. They recognized that Carissa had talent, but they were never going to love her apartment. The only way she would have won is if he had screwed up majorly.

Although Margaret was always classily dressed.

You know what I don't understand about the Top Design complaints? People who don't like Todd Oldham and/or Jonathan Adler. If anything, I just wanted MORE of those two crazy gays.

I hated them both. Todd Oldham always sounded like he was reading from a script, I hate that. When he was one on one with the designers, really talking, I liked him. When he was "on", it was horrible. And you could tell the difference easily.

I hated Jonathan Adler's ties and lack of socks. LA or not, if you are wearing a tie, you should be wearing socks. Plus, his patterns were crazy, and not always complimentary (IMHO). The "see you later decorator" was STUPID. Maybe the reason that he couldn't sell it is that he thought so, too, but it should have been eliminated. if you catch phrase sucks, get a new one, or don't use one.

Man, I knew I was going to be cranky today because I'm a moron who doesn't go to bed when she should, but you guys, just now I basically turned to myself and said, "Dude. You must chill."

Top Design was destined to be less successful, I think -- at least with Top Chef, the final criteria, if nothing else, is going to be if it's edible. And with Runway, it's not going to matter how innovative a dress is if it makes the model look like a cow, or falls apart on the Runway. Interior design is a lot more subjective, unless you designed a room with, like, nowhere to sit or something, or a table suspended from the ceiling.

I liked the judge on Shear Genius, Sally Whatever. And the look on Frederick Fekkai's face when some of the models came out was priceless.

Interior design is a lot more subjective, unless you designed a room with, like, nowhere to sit or something, or a table suspended from the ceiling.

yes, this. It shouldn't have mattered if the judges liked it, if the client did. and all of the team challenges were irritating. Yes, you have to learn to work with other people, but you also tend to be able to choose the people you work with.