He can breathe underwater

Atlanteans are air breathers?

Batman could beat the crap out of the fish until it decides to talk to him verbally.

Batman wouldn't have to beat up the fish. He'd just sit still and stare at the fish until the fish got so uncomfortable that the fish confessed to everything.

"Yes! YES! I admit it! I shoved Flipper into the net! STOP STARING AT ME!"

Frank,

Gracias, victor.

Wolverine always seems to make it look like heroics are coming between him and a cold beer.

This is would be Hellboy, too. Right?

Batman could beat the crap out of the fish until it decides to talk to him verbally.

Bwahahaha!! Now I'm cross-polinating genres so I've got Keifer Sutherland as Batman pounding a large-mouth bass in the kisser and yelling "Who are you swimming for?!?!?!?"

but Cyclops seems an undeniable superhero to me.

I totally agree. And, really, I think that one of the places that Joss seems to be going with "Astonishing X-Men" is that "super-hero" may well be a role that Scott's more comfortable with than, say, "Mutant freedom fighter/teacher/activist," or whatever it is they've been doing for the past few years.

Funny how, for Cyclops, the more idealized role comes easier than the more realistic one.

He can breathe underwater (which, OK, so can Supes)

I think Supes just holds his breath.

Funny how, for Cyclops, the more idealized role comes easier than the more realistic one.

That's because he's an ass.

Still -- Storm, Jean, Beast, Colossus -- heroes all, no?

This is would be Hellboy, too. Right?

I always felt comic Hellboy was a hero. But my heroimeter is a bit broken.

I'm now thinking that ita meant "Atlantean compatriots".

If I recall correctly, Aquaman, being half-human, can stay out of the water longer than his fellow Atlanteans. I don't remember if other Atlanteans can talk to fish like he does.

Not quite up there with the Submariner, but so close.

Not as big an asshat, certainly. Namor's a prick; Aquaman's only a tool.

I'm now thinking that ita meant "Atlantean compatriots".

Doesn't compatriot mean fellow-people-from-where-you're-from?

Main Entry: com·pa·tri·ot

Pronunciation: k&m-'pA-trE-&t, käm-, -trE-"ät, chiefly British -'pa-

Function: noun

Etymology: French compatriote, from Late Latin compatriota, from Latin com- + Late Latin patriota fellow countryman -- more at PATRIOT

1 : a person born, residing, or holding citizenship in the same country as another

2 : COMPEER, COLLEAGUE

I was going by the second definition. In which case the League counts as "compatriots". And since we were talking about "superheroes", the context led me to that.

I now see that you meant the first definition.