My MiL writes an article for my old hometown newspaper. (I'm sure many of you remember the Wedding Etiquette article debacle) However, I know there are Buffistas with high school or soon to be high school age children and I thought that it was prudent to pass this along. I thought myself to be pretty knowledgeable of the No Child Left Behind, what with being from a family of teachers and counting several teachers as friends, but I had NO IDEA about this.
“THOUGHTS AT LARGE” COLUMN – 9-29-05 – "NCLB goes too far" by Kathleen Conat
The situation is this: the Pentagon has admitted it has a database with personal information about children. Our children. It's been collecting that data for the past three years.
The No Child Left Behind Law has a little known requirement, Section 9528, that all high schools must turn over information on students or risk losing federal funding. The information includes names, addresses, e-mail addresses, cell phone numbers, ethnicity, Social Security numbers and areas of study. That information is turned over to military recruiters.
The Pentagon's database now holds information on 30 million young men and women 16 to 25 years of age. The database is updated daily and distributed monthly to all branches of the armed services.
What is the worst part of this, in my view, is that school administrators were told they could not notify the parents that this was happening. Yes, you read that right. The federal government decided to bypass parents so they could contact kids -- underage, still living at home, teenagers – and recruit them into the military.
Rep. David Vitter, (R) Louisiana, is the one responsible for the insertion of Section 9528 into the No Child Left Behind Law. Evidently, no one really questioned it at the time. Maybe legislators were as unaware of it as the parents of America?
Section 9528 is a clear violation of the Privacy Act, which requires notification and public comment whenever new data is being compiled on individuals by any branch of the government. But, in 2002, the Pentagon contracted with a private marketing firm, BeNow, Inc., to begin "consolidating the data for greater efficiency." There is now speculation that Department of Defense leaders thought this would get them around the Privacy Act.
Certainly, it is clear Section 9528 was added to NCLB in order to circumvent parental controls. As parents and citizens learn more about this, I'm not the only one who is angry. A coalition of parent-activists has been started, called Leave My Child Alone, which shows parents how to "opt out." Its Internet site can be accessed at www.leavemychildalone.org.
I spoke with Ypsilanti High School Principal Eric Graves after learning about the information being handed over. He said that recently the law has been reinterpreted so parents can now notify the school not to send the information. As long as a letter is on file, he will not send the data to the Feds.
Graves will be sending out a letter to parents from the American Civil Liberties Union, explaining what is happening and how parents can "opt out" of both the schools' requirement to send the data and get their child's information off the Pentagon's main database. Because, you see, if your child is over the age of 16, that information was already sent last year – before you knew this section of the law existed.
Graves stressed that unless a parent signs a letter stating his or her child's information is to be withheld from the government, he has to send it along. But, that simple letter will allow him to keep your child's information private. There's even a way for a student over the age of majority to "opt out" on his own.
Graves said the school is contacted by the military every year. Military recruiters sit in the school's cafeteria with the same access to junior and senior students as the college and university recruiters have.
That's fine. That's out in the open. So, why do the Pentagon and, evidently, Congress feel the need to sneak around behind our (continued...)