Muppets LotR (slightly edited, I'm afraid):
victor infante: A Muppets' Lord of the Rings:
Kermit as Aragorn (of course)
Gonzo as Frodo
Fozzy as Sam
Animal as Golem (PRECIOUS! PREEECIOUS!!!)
Scooter & Robin as Pippen & Merry?
Ms. Havisham: (disturbing images of Gonzo wearing the Ring on his nose)
That leaves Miss Piggy for Arwen and Janice for Eowyn?
Who should the Swedish Chef be?
Elena: Miss Piggy would have to be Arwen; though it might be nice to have her play Eowyn, throwing herself at Aragorn and all.
victor infante: Who should the Swedish Chef be? Lord Elrond.
"We are going into the West. Bork. Bork. Bork."
And I take back Scooter. he should Boromir.
Matt the Bruins fan: So would Sam the Eagle be Gandalf, or would we go the Stadtler & Waldorf route with Gandalf and Saruman?
billytea: Who should the Swedish Chef be? Saruman! Can't you just see him shouting "A new power is rising! Fetch the boom-boom!"
Beverly: go the Stadtler & Waldorf route with Gandalf and Saruman? Yes, yes! But which is who? Does it matter?
Theodosia: I really want to see the Muppet horses of the Rohirrim.
And Mr. flea (yup, I'm catching up, but I laughed out loud at the Muppets-casting, so I couldn't wait):
really liked how they showed the split personality of Gollum. It figures he would develop one when he was down there all alone for so long. He didn't even have a volleyball.