Harrow: You didn't have to wound that man. Mal: Yeah, I know, it was just funny.

'Shindig'


All Ogle, No Cash -- It's Not Just Annoying, It's Un-American

Discussion of episodes currently airing in Un-American locations (anything that's aired in Australia is fair game), as well as anything else the Un-Americans feel like talking about or we feel like asking them. Please use the show discussion threads for any current-season discussion.

Add yourself to the Buffista map while you're here by updating your profile.


Typo Boy - May 11, 2010 11:31:15 am PDT #8949 of 9843
Calli: My people have a saying. A man who trusts can never be betrayed, only mistaken.Avon: Life expectancy among your people must be extremely short.

I gather that by Alternative Vote, what is intended is the same as Australia uses for their lower house, what in the U.S. is called instant run-off?

So you still have single member districts, but then you name your first, second etc choices? And then if nobody wins the constituency with an outright majority in essence a formula figures out who would have won a run-off based on 2nd choice, 3rd choice and so on?


Jars - May 11, 2010 11:31:54 am PDT #8950 of 9843

Argh I'm puking a bit in my mouth at the pictures of the Cameronbot in no. 10.

I've got my eye on you, Cambot, you oily entitled little gob.


Seska (the Watcher-in-Training) - May 11, 2010 12:00:33 pm PDT #8951 of 9843
"We're all stories, in the end. Just make it a good one, eh?"

Argh I'm puking a bit in my mouth at the pictures of the Cameronbot in no. 10.

His smug speech was just dreadful.

On the bright side, there were protesters outside Number 10 as he went in!


Jars - May 11, 2010 12:06:24 pm PDT #8952 of 9843

Yes! I heard booing even! Someone sent me a Facebook invite for an anti-Conservative deomonstration in Trafalgar Sq on Saturday. Which is quick work I think. If it was a pro-human decency and compassion demonstration I might go.


Fiona - May 11, 2010 9:28:47 pm PDT #8953 of 9843

Argh I'm puking a bit in my mouth at the pictures of the Cameronbot in no. 10.

Right there with you, Jars.

The poor old LibDems really are screwed. First caught between the devil and the deep blue sea; now the Tories are going to blame them for everything that goes wrong the next couple of years.

The stupid alternative vote is going to go to a referendum and end up setting back the case for proper electoral reform by many years. What really gets on my nerves is when the anti-PR people scaremonger that PR will end the link between MPs and constituencies. Um, no. I live in a country with PR and it still elects local MPs; it can be done. But the British people are not being educated about the possibilities.

The only good thing to come out of this will be if the Tories make themselves so unpopular they don't get re-elected for a generation, as Mervyn King predicts.

On the other hand: more Murdoch and bye-bye BBC as we know it.


Fiona - May 11, 2010 9:33:45 pm PDT #8954 of 9843

OTOH... has anybody else noticed how many people are wearing purple these days? Gordon Brown was wearing a purple suit and tie when he resigned as leader of the Labour party. Nick Clegg hat a purple tie on the other day. And then yesterday SamCam was in a purple dress.

The Electoral Reform have been using purple as their protest colour. Coincidence? I hope not.


Seska (the Watcher-in-Training) - May 11, 2010 9:55:41 pm PDT #8955 of 9843
"We're all stories, in the end. Just make it a good one, eh?"

Yes, at least some of that purple is about electoral reform - it's been everywhere here - it started the day we started calling for change in the voting system. Note how Clegg and Brown have been wearing purple but Cameron's been wearing traditional blue. Doesn't bode well.

If it was a pro-human decency and compassion demonstration I might go.

I'm going to stay involved with Power 2010 and 38 Degrees, the reform groups - I'm hoping for more demonstrations of the kind that I couldn't make on Saturday. We need to push for an early-as-possible re-election I think.

The poor old LibDems really are screwed. First caught between the devil and the deep blue sea; now the Tories are going to blame them for everything that goes wrong the next couple of years.

Not just the Tories. Twitter etc suggests the people really hate them right now, which is new for the Lib Dems. I'm used to my party being unpopular, but this is something else! I'm really, really angry that Clegg has sold us out for a few seats in the cabinet. Now he'd better do some good and keep the Tories in check, or I predict thousands of us will give up on the Lib Dems for good.

The stupid alternative vote is going to go to a referendum and end up setting back the case for proper electoral reform by many years.

I'm a big supporter of electoral reform, and I don't have a major problem with the AV system. I once wanted PR, but this election (with big BNP and UKIP wins) has persuaded me that there's a case for a middle way (ugh, and I sound like a Blairite). I do wish we could have a referendum with different voting options put to the people. But I can't see the Tories doing that.


Fiona - May 11, 2010 10:38:09 pm PDT #8956 of 9843

I'm really, really angry that Clegg has sold us out for a few seats in the cabinet.

But seriously though: what else could he have done? If he'd gone with Labour the Tory shouting would have been at least as loud. At least this way there should be a stable government for a while. Get some advance on electoral reform, try and hold back the worst of the Tory excesses, let them bite the bullet on economic reform and let Labour regroup post-Blair-Brown. Sounds OK, if they can pull it off.

I'm not convinced by AV, it doesn't sound like proper electoral reform to me. PR is fairest. In Germany there's a 5% threshold, so it's very rare that extremist parties get a toehold.

And no, the Tories will never let the people chose.

On a side note, I realised a couple of days ago that I must know Nick Clegg. He was at my best friend's college when we were at Uni.

Oh, and another I'm-getting-older moment: not only do I remember Margaret Thatcher being elected, but the new Prime Minister is only one year older than me. How did that happen?


billytea - May 11, 2010 10:48:46 pm PDT #8957 of 9843
You were a wrong baby who grew up wrong. The wrong kind of wrong. It's better you hear it from a friend.

I'm not convinced by AV, it doesn't sound like proper electoral reform to me. PR is fairest. In Germany there's a 5% threshold, so it's very rare that extremist parties get a toehold.

I'm a big fan of preferential voting of course, and think it would be a good step forward. I also prefer a system that doesn't make coalitions the norm. However, I agree with the need to provide representation for minority parties. A hybrid constituency/PR system is worth looking at (New Zealand introduced such a system relatively recently). In Australia we have both elements - the lower house is all single-member electorates, but the upper house has 12 members from each state, elected via a PR system. Since the 70s, the balance of power there has usually been out of the hands of the two major parties.

Fiona, have you heard of a board game called Die Macher? It's based on Germany's rather idiosyncratic electoral system, and has quite a devoted following among board game aficionados.


Fiona - May 11, 2010 11:33:32 pm PDT #8958 of 9843

Fiona, have you heard of a board game called Die Macher?

Actually, I haven't, but I should probably look it out. Sounds like something B. might be into. He's already mastered The Settlers of Catan....

However, I agree with the need to provide representation for minority parties.

In the British system, we're not even talking minority parties, but parties with around a quarter of the popular vote. It's pure fluke that the LibDems are finally able to punch their weight. If they're not careful it won't happen again.