Critique was said to be a mean thing to do or something.

Poor delicate flowers.

Meanwhile, half the people on my FL appear to have stopped talking to each other over... something (thinking about it gives me whiplash), BBF just settled down, Smallville's on F-H, and, oh yeah--Fandom Wank's been deleted by its own mods. Or one of them. We're uncertain WTF is up with that.

This is why I've decided they're all crazy people and I'm'a go on just talking to, you know, sane people I like.

Fandom Wank's been deleted by its own mods.

Holy cow, really? Wow. That's... pretty impressive.

Holy cow, really? Wow. That's... pretty impressive.

It did done eat itself.

Ooh! My very first fanfic list did that! One day it was there, and the next... poof!

Mind you, it did turn out to be one of those, you know, many-heads-sprouting things.

Most of the time, I wouldn't have worried that a story might feature our heroine being molested by monkeys, but this time, I was worried.

I'm... having a post-traumatic flashback to that one story with Nikita and the Doberman.

t cries

Thank you shrift, now I'm having a flash to that one with Blair and the... shudder

Dobermans, however, don't much bother me. Anais Nin kind of desensitized me.

Holy cow, really? Wow. That's... pretty impressive.

Isn't that fabulous? I mean, tell me that's not completely appropriate as a way to go. (I don't suppose it'll actually go go, but still.)

Yeah, the vidding kerfuffle was list-based--Nummy Treat, apparently. Sisabet posted about it. Then there was a big argument about the politics of othering that I think branched off of the fanfic_hate thing, but none of it happened on my flist, so, you know, I'm a little unclear. And then something about academic usage of words that may or may not be racist? And then a bunch of posts were deleted?

You know how it is. *shrug*

Ah. I recognize this argument. Oddly enough, I'm so sheltered I've hardly been subjected to it myself. I can't even communicate with the folks who don't sweat over their fic.

I should post Fialka's beta notes on Bellum Interruptum. I was absolutely furious about what she had to say. Enraged. Didn't want to do it, didn't think it needed to be done. My story, mine! This is work! Total territorial response. And this to one of my closest friends, online or off.

You know what? A lot of what she said was right, and the story is better for it.

What's the saying? Not worth doing if it's not worth doing right?

My story, mine!

Oh, lord, this. I know this bugaboo very well.

The Elite Vidding Bitch Cabal icons have been around for awhile. I think they were made in response to another kerfuffle and have been pulled out for the current one.

Frankly, I'm not surprised onlist vid critiquing imploded, Serge (ds mailing list) tried to do a fic of the week thing and I left right when it was getting really wanky.