Buffista Movies 5: Development Hell
A place to talk about movies--old and new, good and bad, high art and high cheese. It's the place to place your kittens on the award winners, gossip about upcoming fims and discuss DVD releases and extras. Spoiler policy: White font all plot-related discussion until a movie's been in wide release two weeks, and keep the major HSQ in white font until two weeks after the video/DVD release.
Have you seen any other Miyazaki movies? I liked Howl a lot, but his fans are fairly divided in opinion. I've watched a handful of Miyazaki movies both with and without the subtitles, and the story is ALWAYS better in the original Japanese, but the Japanese voice artists sometimes bug me.
Anyway, skipping the Lupin III movie, which I didn't care much about, and Sherlock Hound, which I haven't seen, I'd rank his movies thus:
1. Spirited Away
2. My Neighbor Totoro
3. Princess Mononoke
4. Howl's Moving Castle
5. Nausicaa
6. Porco Rosso
7. Castle in the Sky
8. Kiki's Delivery Service
Of the movies he worked on but didn't direct, I really like Pom Poko, thought Whisper of the Heart was ok, and never saw The Cat Returns.
So, for someone that wants to fill this egregious gap in her film education, which ones would the Buffistas recommend I start with?
Okay, ranking Howl above Nausicaa I can understand, because for some reason there are plenty of otherwise right-thinking people who don't care for that one. But ranking Howl above Porco Rosso? That's just crazyness!
I could lend you my grey-market boxed set, megan.
Eh, Porco Rosso was alright, but I didn't think there was much there there. I liked Howl's story more.
Megan, I'd start with Spirited Away or Totoro. That said, the first one I saw was Mononoke, which was also fantastic.
which ones would the Buffistas recommend I start with?
I've seen only three of the the films listed about, but I'd say, go with Spirited Away. I found the environmental messages in Princess Mononoke way too heavy-handed for my liking -- something SA does with a lot more subtlety. SA also has a great balance of humour and wonder.
I've seen only three of the the films listed about, but I'd say, go with Spirited Away. I found the environmental messages in Princess Mononoke way too heavy-handed for my liking -- something SA does with a lot more subtlety. SA also has a great balance of humour and wonder.
I've only seen
Mononoke
and
Spirited Away,
but unlike most of the world, I liked
Mononoke
better. I don't think I really got
Spirited Away.
Whereas
Mononoke
had a pretty clear plot with giant wolves and shit. I watched the American dubbing, for the record, though I think I did watch SA subtitled. Maybe. If it got an American dubbing, then that's what would have been on the DVD.
That's all the Miyazaki I've seen, though I should see more, especially since the creators of
Avatar
note him as an obvious influence.
I saw both
Nausicaa
and
Laputa
(preferred titles to Valley of the Wind and Castle in the Sky, respectively) in the original Japanese without subtitles the first time. Still loved them both dearly.
I could lend you my grey-market boxed set, megan.
Tom, as always, you are made of awesome. That would be great. I would, of course, pay postage. Or, my friends that live near you (I think you recently saw them at msbelle's) are coming down here Thanksgiving weekend. S walks home by your place everyday.
While you're in lending mode, you wouldn't happen to have any current BSG episodes, would you? My dvr had to be replaced yet again and, due to a severe misinformation campaign by Atlantic Broadband, I lost all the episodes I had been saving while I was waiting to catch up with past seasons.
I've never seen any Miyazaki films, but I'm thinking I should add some to my Netflix queue.
I seriously love 1776, and recommend getting the DVD, which has the extended director's cut including "Cool Conservative Men", and not the butchered-by-Jack-Warner theatrical release. I wish I had seen the concert version that was done locally a few years back that was gender-neutral casting (female John Adams, male Abigail), which I heard was just amazing!