t natter some more

Stop insulting Pylea. I love those episodes. Fred + dance of Joy + general fun all around.

t /natter

Nobody answered my original question. How much posting interest is necessary to make a new thread worthwhile, and what are the drawbacks that you (we) care enough about to make it even a posable question?

Nobody answered my original question.

Probably because no one knows. We're making it up as we go along.

well not really. A new thread would need a vote, no?

What does it take to have a vote pass? simple majority or those who vote?

Simple majority of those who vote, as long as 42 or more people vote.

Yeah, but he used the word "worthwhile". That implies more to me than just "how do we get a new thread created?".

ok true, but we as a group are never gonna agree on what is worthwhile.

That implies more to me than just "how do we get a new thread created?".

Definitely. I don't want to start a new thread if the "community" as a whole will then grumble about it, even if I can get a vote pushed through.

I'm just curious about what the people of the buffista community feel would make a thread that added to the completeness of what we have. Specifically: if you, as a person, aren't interested in a thread, then how many of your fellow buffistas do you think SHOULD be interested in the thread for you to consider it worth it's own separate world, that might become a separate 'sub-community', eventually?

I mean, I, personally, don't watch The O.C. (yet), but I would be perfectly happy for there to be an O.C. thread, as I think at least 15 or 20 regular buffistas would probably post in there, and enjoy the discussion. I don't think a Law and Order thread, however, would make much sense, because I don't think there're that many buffistas that follow new developments (though i may be wrong, and a bureaucracy discussion about such a thread might prove me wrong, I dunno)

Also, how do you as people decide whether a new thread would be a good thing? What do you weigh against the idea of "people would enjoy posting in this thread"? Is it the fear of many new members, the fear of technical problems with the server, the annoyance of more threads on your homepage, or what?

(P.S. Is there somewhere I can donate to the b.org server fund? I'd love to, it seems entirely worth it.)

if you, as a person, aren't interested in a thread, then how many of your fellow buffistas do you think SHOULD be interested in the thread for you to consider it worth it's own separate world, that might become a separate 'sub-community', eventually?

I don't have much of an opinion on this specific topic, mostly because I don't need to. If the vote says we're going to have an all Xhosa all the time thread -- then we will. If the noise:signal ratio overwhelms me and saps my enjoyment of the board, then I leave. I can't quantify, beyond quorum or whatever (and even that was pretty arbitrary) how many Buffistas it takes to matter.

how do you as people decide whether a new thread would be a good thing?

A million different ways, I bet.

Is there somewhere I can donate to the b.org server fund?

Paypal donations@buffistas.org.

Hmmm... I think most of the new threads created since we've been here have fallen into two categories:

1) Obvious fit with our original mission of Jossy goodness. E.g. "Jossverse in other media" (created when Fray was published), or "Minearverse" (Tim being Joss' right hand man on two of his shows).

2) Topics overwhelming other threads. E.g. the pretty elves.

There's also been the movies and music threads, but IIRC those met with a bit more resistance.

I don't want to start a new thread if the "community" as a whole will then grumble about it, even if I can get a vote pushed through.

Ah, but that would become abundantly clear in the discussion process.