We're Literary 2: To Read Makes Our Speaking English Good
There's more to life than watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer! No. Really, there is! Honestly! Here's a place for Buffistas to come and discuss what it is they're reading, their favorite authors and poets. "Geez. Crack a book sometime."
I could imagine cross-dressing as having at least as many reasons.
I think it's pretty sure. You're going to encounter men who just plain like the feel of wearing skirts, women who think tuxes look better on them, etc, etc -- are you looking at crossdressing as a whole, or just the erotic part?
Also, are you looking at partial crossdressing? The man in the business suit and the frilly panties? The girl in y-fronts under her skirt?
I'm looking at cross-dressing as a whole, I think.
Huh. I hadn't even thought about partial cross-dressing. Yes, sure, I'd be interested in that, too, I think.
I was thinking of trying to write a story that would have a cross-dresser as a character, and figured it would be a good thing to do the research and not just have a To Wong Foo rip off. So I thought, ok, get a book or two, maybe a cultural study and a biography, and learn something. But, as with most things involving humans, 'tis complex.
I appreciate everyone's comments on the topic. They're helping me figure out just what the heck I'm looking for, which should be very useful. Thanks!
Unfortunately I have no answers. But I'm good with questions.
While we're kinda on the tip, maybe here's a better place to ask about references on gender identity (Kate?). I've been reading a bit about various physical gender...uhh...unconventionalities, IAS (partial and complete) and the like, and was wondering about the psychological components, but know not where to look.
ita, you're interested in phenotypically intersex people? Some sources:
Dreger, A. (2003). Notes on the Treatment of Intersex. Intersex Society of North America. [link]
This is an article about the surgery-centered model (pick a sex, make the kid as much like that sex as possible) and the patient-centered model (hey, when you're ready, decide what sex you want to be) of treatment of intersex children (all types).
Sax, Leonard. (2002) How Common is Intersex? A Response to Anne Fausto-Sterling. Journal of Sex Research.
[link]
Sax, Fausto-Sterling, and Blackless are the big three names in current intersex research right now.
And here's a law approach: Hermer, Laura. (2001). Surgical Revision of Intersex Children. [link]
There's also an interesting film called "First Do No Harm", put out by ISNA, involving interviews with adults who were assigned to sexes in childhood, and a rountable of psychologists, parents, and intersex adults. It's a strongly editorial film (as you might guess), but it addresses psychological outcome directly (which a lot of surgical approaches seem to fail to do).
Thanks.
Do those dwell on the psychological aspects?
eta: Because I'm finding lots of stuff from a phenotypical angle, and am interested now in people who
feel
they're the wrong gender.
#1 and #3, yes, (#1 moreso). The video most of all.
ETA: Discovery Health also has an hour-long video segment about congenital adrenal hyperplasia (girl with boyish sex-parts), which you might be able to find at a library. It follows a family that ends up going for the surgical approach, and shows the decision-making that goes into it all, and the parents' angst about choosing.
ita, one book I've heard a lot about is As Nature Made Him. It's a very sad story, not least of all b/c the subject of the bio recently killed himself.
[ETA but I just realized it's not what you're looking for, since David Reimer was born with unambigous male genitalia that were damaged during circumcision.]
Thanks Nutty and Dani.
The surreal thing about Middlesex was that
there was no gender dysmorphia at all -- just a change in clothes, hair and walking, switch up some language, but he wasn't a girly boy or a boyish girl.
Okay, maybe not
the
surreal thing, but one that made me wonder about the reality of it all.
Actually, Dani, that is precisely what I'm interested in -- what makes a boy feel like a boy, and a girl like a girl. How did he know he was wrong?
I think I've seen a TV show on that case, and had forgotten the name of the book.
ita, I'd recommend Anne Fausto-Sterling's Sexing the Body as an introduction to both the biological and the psychic/cultural sides of this whole area; the author is trained in both biology and (iirc) sociology, so she's one of the rare people who's able to talk across the usual disciplinary boundaries.