Buffybot ,'Dirty Girls'
A thread to discuss naming threads, board policy, new thread suggestions, and anything else that has to do with board administration and maintenance. Guaranteed to include lively debate and polls. Natter discouraged, but not deleted.
Current Stompy Feet: ita, Jon B, DXMachina, P.M. Marcontell, Liese S., amych
If you got the seconds first, then your proposal goes live first, I think.
Which makes it impossible to vote between two constructive alternatives ("10" or "20").
From what I gather, unless the people in the discussion can persuade the person making the proposal they have no effect on what goes on the ballot.
From what I gather, unless the people in the discussion can persuade the person making the proposal they have no effect on what goes on the ballot.
Yes.
Which makes it impossible to vote between two constructive alternatives ("10" or "20").
No. Not if the proposer wants to offer those alternatives. And that's your definition of constructive, and does not hold true for everyone.
No, a mandate is a dictated course of action. There's no reason you can't have a mandate from just one person.
We're using different definitions for "mandate". I'll quit using it.
So what does it take to propose something? Can I propose whatever I want, word it however I want and put it to a vote 48 hours later?
So what does it take to propose something? Can I propose whatever I want, word it however I want and put it to a vote 48 hours later?
You'd need people to second it, and it would be voted on several days later.
How many people?
How many people?
Four, I believe. I think that's what that vote decided.
Voting results to date:
Got it now.
I guess my concern is about how the phrasing of a ballot effects the outcome and that one person determines the phrasing.
For instance, if the matter just voted on had been worded:
Any ten posters can (upon stating publically within 24 hours of each other) for any reason officially censure (and ultimately ban) another poster.
The votes may well have lined up differently.
So, come June 29th if I'm still concerned about how ballots are written I can propose something.
I'm probably a bit late, I got interupted by a co-worker (the noive of some people! :)
How many seconders to turn a proposal into a vote?
4
How many voters to makle a vote count?
42
How long before you can propose an end to voting?
6 months
The moritorium on moritoriums can be reviewed in 3 months. Every other vote stands at 6 month.
The initial vote, to approve voting, is here jengod "Sunnydale Press" Mar 3, 2003 12:00:27 am EST
And I think it's important to remember that 135 people voted on the subject of voting. 120 people said, yes, I want voting to be the way that things are decided.
With the way this board works, that's an overwhelming number of people. And either definition of "mandate" would work here.
Yeah, they'd probably have lined up differently. That's a different proposal.
That's not just wording, that's concept. Assuming, for the moment, that you didn't mean to swap 24 for 48 -- msbelle's prime proposal was about how to institute an action. Whether that becomes a censure or a ban was NOT up for vote, as it's already been decided. But it is in your proposal.