Willow ,'The Killer In Me'
A thread to discuss naming threads, board policy, new thread suggestions, and anything else that has to do with board administration and maintenance. Guaranteed to include lively debate and polls. Natter discouraged, but not deleted.
Current Stompy Feet: ita, Jon B, DXMachina, P.M. Marcontell, Liese S., amych
But how do No Preference votes factor in?
They count toward making the 42-vote minimum, but don't count one way or another toward the...
Oh.
Huh.
Okay, this was hashed out at great length when we voted on the concept of No Preference in the first place, I know it was. When was that, last March or sometime around then?
I can't find where we said if you need a majority of votes with a preference, or an overall majority of votes cast. That is to say, I'm not sure the combining Farscape/due South/Smallville threads vote did pass.
If we count no preferences when determining the majority, aren't we basically counting them as "no's"? My understanding has always been that no preferences counted towards the 42, but if a vote went 3 yes, 1 no, 89 NP, the yesses took it.
I don't know that I have a reference either, though.
I rather dislike the squishing together of names. It's kind of tacky.
And yeah, I whitefronted last year for Stargate--but we're pretty torrent-less this year, so I think we'll all be on the same airing schedule.
A topic for the discussion of Due South, Smallville, and Farscape. Beware possible invasions of Stargate, Highlander, or pretty much anything else that captures our fancy. Expect Adult Content and discussion of the Big Gay Sex.
I like this for the slug. It mentions the Big Three fandoms that we're combining and allows for drift of other fandoms. The "expect adult content and BGS" bit lets users know that slash-talk will happen, but that it's not necessarily the focus of the thread.
Okay, that's one vote. (Well, two, since I thought it was okay enough to suggest too...) We're still hashing out the title, but does anyone object to this as the slug? Think anything needs to be added or removed?
My understanding has always been that no preferences counted towards the 42, but if a vote went 3 yes, 1 no, 89 NP, the yesses took it.
That's what I remember too, FWIW.
The NPs count towards meeting the quorum and if the quorum is met then the Yeses and Nos are counted.
But how do No Preference votes factor in?
From Laura "Sunnydale Press" Mar 19, 2003 12:06:31 am PST:
ITEM 3: VOTER TURNOUT
How many Buffistas does it take to make a vote count?
42
Do votes of "no preference" count toward this?
Yes
Which means that if the total number of votes cast (Yes and No and No Preference) reach 42, the vote counts. If there are more votes for Yes than No than the vote passes as Yes, regardless of how many voted No Preference.
If there were 43 votes, 40 No Preference, 2 Yes and 1 No, the vote is still Yes.
So, in this vote ( DXMachina "Sunnydale Press" Aug 27, 2003 4:06:03 am PDT ), there were 55 for Yes, 29 for No and 39 No Preference - it definitely met the 42 criteria, and there were more Yes than No, so it passed.
[Edit: massive x-post]
I like the slug.
Thank you, Nilly!
Jesse, my fault memory says that we had to go back and, on our second vote, vote on what "majority" meant. I.e. that it was 50%+1, not 66%, and that votes of no preference did not count toward what was 50%, only toward the 42-minimum voter turnout.
I haven't the cites with me, but goodness, we sure talked about it!
What do you think about the desire to be specific in the thread title - listing shows - to try to keep the volume down?
Sounds good, either in the thread title or the slug. I do think that some category-name like "Combined TV Fandom" is more flexible and less clunky than just a list of names, although I'll note there hasn't been a good punnish suggestion yet. Alas!