Back channel harassment over gerunds? That's serious!

To me, it is clearly thing. I've never heard think until yesterday.

I need to get out of bed but don't want to. Sammy is still asleep next to me and he is the perfect size for cuddling.

Aw, Sammy.

Thanks for all the compliments on the house! Now we just have to, you know, actually buy it.

Also, I do not want to live in either Nashville or Indianapolis, but I am severely jealous of the price of Kate's house and of my sister's.

Everyone should move to Nashville! Although this house is definitely on the lower end of the market around here, especially for one in such good shape. East Nashville is still up-and-coming, which helps; this is a neighborhood that (as far as we can tell) is pretty close to the tipping point, but not *quite* there yet.

Man, one all day training session and no internet at home and you get so far behind:

it's totally "think" and "pipe"

Apparently the NZ eventing team got arrested for drinking in a non-drinking area.

Here is a much sweeter picture of Toddy and a fan.

Dressage starts today ( Carl Hester of GB is currently in first place)

Pictures from the trot-up which was, I believe, yesterday.

I missed the link to the Kate house! But YAY! So happy for you.

I wondered how over 100 posts could have happened in Natter overnight. I should have known.

Apparently the NZ eventing team got arrested for drinking in a non-drinking area.

My scandal of choice at the Olympics so far has been the badminton: [link]

Nice of badminton to set up their tournament so that it pays to lose in the early rounds.

Billytea, are you telling me that my interpretation is unconvincing, or wrong, or what? I'm not trying to sway you--I'm just describing the truth. You don't have to buy into it--that's merely what the expression means. Your acceptance won't make it any more true, just like your rejection doesn't make it any more false. That's simply what the expression has always meant. And the "thing" expression is an eggcorn, and it doesn't matter how long the posts in defense of "thing" get--still eggcorn, and "think" still original and meaning what I said.

I'm not looking for converts--I mean it when I say I'm confused by why people would defiantly go with something they know is an error. If you want to retcon all sorts of meaning into the error and explain why you feel the original shouldn't have made sense...still a retcon.

ok, also until this conversation, never heard the word eggcorn before.

We say it the way we do because it is the way we have always heard it said and it is an accepted (by most) way of saying the phrase and it has been in use more prolifically then the original phrase. It makes sense to us.

I say "under God" in the pledge of allegiance too. It's not original to the pledge. It does change the meaning of it. I don't actually like it in there, BUT, it is how I learned it, how it sounds right to my brain and how I continue to say it.

Billytea, are you telling me tat my interpretation is unconvincing, or wrong, or what?

Unconvincing, I suppose. I've never come across the expression before, so maybe it's used in an idiomatic fashion; but the meaning you presented doesn't seem to be in line with the words used.

Your acceptance won't make it any more true, just like your rejection doesn't make it any more false.

True. My line of reasoning, however, may indicate whether it was true or false, independent of what you or I thought it meant.

To further the issue, Vortex stated that the earliest usage was:

"Conroy lives in Troy and thinks he is a coming fighter. This gentleman has another think coming. It is probable that McCoy will next meet Joe Choynski."

My reading of this statement is that it wasn't even addressed to Conroy. I don't see how it can be read as saying "Think again"; I do see how it can mean "You're about to find out how wrong you are" (or more precisely, "[Conroy] is about to find out how wrong [he] is". When he fights Choynski, I take it.)

And the "thing" expression is an eggcorn, and it doesn't matter how long the posts in defense of "thing" get--still eggcorn, and "think" still original and meaning what I said.

I have numbered... stuff!

1. What's an eggcorn?
2. In this thread, near as I can tell, your use of the phrase was simply to seek confirmation that other people used "think" rather than "thing". Is there a use elsewhere that provides context to "meaning what I said"?
3. As you'll recall, my position on the matter is that "you've got another thing coming" makes perfect sense in any case. I am not saying there is a single phrase, and it has to be either "think" or "thing". I'm saying that regardless of whether people somewhere use "you've got another think coming", "you've got another thing coming" is a grammatically correct and usable phrase in its own right. And since it doesn't have to start with "You think that...", and I don't recall ever hearing it in that context, I don't see them as being in exact equivalence. (IOW, FLYING SQUIRREL SUPREMACIST!)
4. Lists are fun!

I can't really speak to the error/retcon stuff, as I regard it as neither. (Even if there had to be One True Phrase, given even "thing" has been around for almost a century, I feel the statute of limitations has passed on demanding modern communication find the original more congenial.)

I've never heard of an eggcorn before, either, and my head keeps trying to make it an egg cream.