The Tobey Maguire hate is so surprising! I mean, I don't love him, but mostly he's just not on my radar at all.
Buffista Movies 7: Brides for 7 Samurai
A place to talk about movies--old and new, good and bad, high art and high cheese. It's the place to place your kittens on the award winners, gossip about upcoming fims and discuss DVD releases and extras. Spoiler policy: White font all plot-related discussion until a movie's been in wide release two weeks, and keep the major HSQ in white font until two weeks after the video/DVD release.
I just read this on wikipedia:
During many of his auditions, Maguire found himself auditioning for roles opposite another rising actor, Leonardo DiCaprio. The pair struck up a fast friendship and made an informal pact to help each other get parts in their movies/TV shows/other projects. For example, both auditioned for the same part in the 1990 TV series based on the 1989 comedy Parenthood. DiCaprio got the part, and Maguire later got a guest role at least partially due to DiCaprio's recommendation. The same scenario played itself out during casting for the 1993 movie This Boy's Life (featuring Robert De Niro as the lead); DiCaprio got the main teen role (coincidentally, the character was named "Toby") and Maguire got a part as one of Toby's friends.
So maybe they wanted to work together?
He's one of two perfect examples of actors who's very voice makes me want to commit violence. (The other one is ... oh, whatshistoes, he starred in Scott Pilgrim. I have the same reaction to him.)
Michael Cera. Heh, well, I think he has a whole hateclub.
Oh yeah, Tobey was in the Pussy Posse. [link]
Tobey Maguire I got nothing. I saw him in Cider House Rules and thought his lack of affect in his voice was brilliant. Then I realized it was just his voice! And it makes me want to kill him.
He literally put me to sleep in that movie, despite the fact that there was a compelling Michael Caine performance too. My ex laughed about it afterwards.
I wonder if the period piece filmmakers are being confused by his resemblance to Elijah Wood, and casting him when they were really initially thinking of Wood?
I like Tobey Maguire. That is all.
Scandals of Hollywood: Marlene Dietrich. A local TV station in NY is airing The Blue Angel later this week. I’m really excited!
I like Tobey Maguire. That is all.
Me too. Especially in Wonder Boys, but also in Spider-Man 2.
I saw a trailer the other day for a period piece about moonshiners, called Brothers, I think. It starred Shia LaBoeuf and he looked utterly out of place. Also, he's just not old enough to carry that role.
Brothers stars Tobey Maguire and Jake Gyllenhall & was released in 2009. I think you're thinking of Lawless, which does have Shia trying to play the brother of Tom Hardy and stand up to Gary Oldman. Which, no. [link]
Also, Nick Cave wrote the screenplay. Which, cool.