I think she sounds (a) like millions of church choir singers, and certainly not amazing and (b) like she's imitating a recording of that song. I don't think she would shine in a performance of a song she doesn't know as well. Some of the qualities she could be trained out of -- like the scooping, her articulation, and maybe overuse of vibrato -- but also she's often flat and her low notes are cringeworthy. She swallows most of them.

ETA: I also think they edited the piece to be Paul Potts part 2 (who was also overrated).

I'm a big sap too, but what I like is that she had the nerve and gumption and got recognized for having a talent without being your usual starlet. One of those teaching moments.

This one was about our beagle Fenris.

That's a fantastic, rather Gertrude Stein bit of writing.

She has a lot more emotion in her voice than the bulk of even really good church choir singers I've known. It strikes a chord in a lot of her listeners.

She deffinately sounds like the les miz recordings but that makes sense -- she hasn't been developing pieces as her own. Why would she? She's like almost every high school singing 'star' that I've ever heard in that way.

The emotion is pretty special. The producers worked it to be certain, but its deffinately real.

Bon, have you heard her singing "Cry Me a River"? It's from 10 years ago and hit teh internets today. It might change your mind. Or, it might not. But you should go listen.

That Cry Me a River sounds really great-- to me it sounds like a totally different singer. Doesn't really change the quality of the Britain's Got Talent performance, though.

Could have been nerves--I read that it was the first time she performed since her mother died. I was impressed but I also may have been reacting to Simon Cowell's face.

She was aiming for Broadway (or West End). Sounded good to me.

Though yes, the song was too low for her in the low parts.

I like the BGT video specifically because of all of the smirking that went on before she performed, and how taken aback the audience and judges were. I thought she sang the song very, very well, especially under the circumstances. But when I heard "Cry Me a River", I felt like a true talent had finally been discovered.

Made it until 4 this time. Progress? Anyway, this is 4 and my brain is still leaking out my ears, so I'm going to clean up and get some pain meds.