I know recency is at play here, but I think the weepiest an episode has made me was Dark Side Of The Moon with the fireworks scene. But the webclips for that ep with Sam being shot and Dean vowing vengeance had already made me cry.

I just noticed a "best quote of S5" meme going around LJ.

Recency is still at play, and I need to think about it more, but off the top of my head "Not for nothing Cas, but the last time someone looked at me like that I got laid" is my current favourite, just because I can't believe they went there, and it cracks me up so hard. But I'm sure there's stuff from earlier episodes that gets me..."Kick it in the ass" is a strong contender, for a whole different vibe.

I just noticed a "best quote of S5" meme going around LJ.

Pudding!

The hardest I ever cried, that I can remember, is when Ellen and Jo died. Like, messy gushing snotty tears. It wasn't pretty.

The other was Dean's speech to dead!Sam. God, that was incredible.

The one I picked, since it was S5 only, was, "Sam, of course, is an abomination." LOVE.

Amy, those were the two teary scenes for me as well.

I'll have to contemplate best line.

The hardest I ever cried, that I can remember, is when Ellen and Jo died. Like, messy gushing snotty tears. It wasn't pretty.

Yeah, same here.

I think the funniest S5 line for me is "It's funnier in Enochian".

Ok Jilli win. Made me giggle and startle the dude giving me a pedicure.

My teariest scene is a draw between "When you were little..." to dead Sam, and Sam dying in Dean's arms. Just-- no. No. Sam.

Although the "How many Tuesdays did you have?" hug is close, as is "--Dean." At the end of No Rest for the Wicked.

Oh, god, Ellen and Jo. Yes, that got me hard too, but happy!Dean got me worse.

There were a lot of great lines in S5. So far, I've liked every one I've seen quoted.

eta: I'm impressed at the sad scenes quoted, and how funny the funny lines are. I'd also submit "Because you're still my big brother" as one of my favourites of the season.

I like: "You hoard toilet paper, hoard it. Hoard it like it's made of gold, because it is."

But I'm sure I'll think of others.

ETA: I just re-watched Jared's turn as Lucifer, thinking I'd love to find a good Lucy quote. No quote, but holy cow, that boy knocked that shit out of the park, it just get's better on re-watch.

"I win. So, I win."

Incidentally, IMDB has 6.1 first airing at September 2010, so there's a rumor to counter the Variety January one.

Oh, please, THIS!

I think the weepiest an episode has made me was Dark Side Of The Moon with the fireworks scene

Right? I have Knockin' on Heaven's Door on my iPhone and each time it shuffles to this song, I'm in that clearing with Dean and wee!Sam.

The other was Dean's speech to dead!Sam

Very much YES. Bawled my eyes out.

eta: Theresa, so sorry about the RIF. It's total BS. :-(