Whose death do you think would hurt the boys the most?

Bobby's is the death they'll feel most, I think. He is a surrogate dad to them.

I think Dean is probably equally in awe of how much each of them have invested in him (perhaps slightly more about Cas), but the history Bobby has must count for more.

Amy, I'd love to apologise, but...no! Dean/Cas makes too much sense. And End!Dean/Cas is all sorts of inevitable, and I like how she did it here.

I swear, every time we discuss who might die in here, this is what goes echoing through my head.

Oh, good. Not just me then.

Amy, I'd love to apologise, but...no! Dean/Cas makes too much sense.

That is one long story, though. I'm going to save it for hiatus. Also because I'm sure Perkins will say I'm not allowed to read it yet.

And to think RTD told people to watch Supernatural if they were upset about Ianto dying. Do I need to make a list of the dead people we've known and loved?

Everybody never lives. Just, sometimes, they come back.

Bobby's never shuffled off the mortal or immortal coil. It's more than time.

aka: Please don't hurt Castiel!

eta:

That is one long story, though. I'm going to save it for hiatus. Also because I'm sure Perkins will say I'm not allowed to read it yet.

Grownups! I swear. Yeah, I guess it is long. I slurped it like crack.

I swear, every time we discuss who might die in here, this is what goes echoing through my head.

Same here.

If the show was actually, really, and truly ending this season, I would want it to end with both the boys dying, and averting the apocalypse with those deaths. And then I would want a final shot of a much older Bobby obviously teaching some early 20s kids about monsters and hunting lore.

Ianto is NOT DEAD. Um, in my imagination.

The only SPN death that I am in such denial about is Ellen. And that's not actual denial, just I dug her so much and I wish she weren't dead.

If the show was actually, really, and truly ending this season, I would want it to end with both the boys dying, and averting the apocalypse with those deaths.

Exactly.

Knowing there is another season makes me completely perplexed as to how it ends but still continues.

And then I would want a final shot of a much older Bobby obviously teaching some early 20s kids about monsters and hunting lore.

Ooooh! Bobby could live on and teach the next gen!

Grownups (granted, who are not sick) would have met their deadlines by now, so.

Everybody never lives. Just, sometimes, they come back.

I'm actually really tired of people coming back. It's such a convenient asspull. I don't want anyone to bring Gabriel back, much as I love him. I sort of hate that Anna was allowed to finagle her way back into the plot when she did.

If Bobby dies, I'd like it to be with some dignity and proper grieving all around. Same with Cas.

Ianto is NOT DEAD. Um, in my imagination.

You and me both, sister. #1 fictional death denial. Do they make therapy for that?

If the show was actually, really, and truly ending this season, I would want it to end with both the boys dying, and averting the apocalypse with those deaths. And then I would want a final shot of a much older Bobby obviously teaching some early 20s kids about monsters and hunting lore.

I'd want one of the boys to die, just so it hurt really bad. That would almost be like healing, for one of them to go on without the other. And teach with Bobby, even.

eta:

I'm actually really tired of people coming back. It's such a convenient asspull.

It's almost a tenet of the world, now, though. And so rarely without angst. I'm of two minds.

An informal poll of the male viewers in the house says Bobby will be the one to go if someone dies.

Sara refused to comment.