Matt, hee!

Looking over the list, I find something that moves the arc along, speaks to the brother bond, to backstory, or foreshadowing in nearly every episode.

3.1 The Magnificent Seven - I disliked this episode, despite the introduction of the season arc and a wonderful character I'd love to see again.

3.2: The Kids Are Alright - If you've seen 5.22 you don't need to see this one, a plot synopsis will do.

3.3: Bad Day at Black Rock - I like this one a lot, and it introduces some recurring characters.

3.4: Sin City - This one is pretty solidly on theme for the season. I liked it, personally.

3.5: Bedtime Stories - Skippable, though I really liked it.

3.6: Red Sky at Morning - one really good scene and some fabulous sfx to geek over, if that's your thing. And boys in tuxes.

3.7: Fresh Blood - violent, but it ties up a secondary arc.

3.8: A Very Supernatural Christmas - must-see, for the bb and the backstory.

3.9: Malleus Maleficarum - ick.

3.10: Dream a Little Dream of Me - pretty solidly on the should-see list.

3.11: Mystery Spot - yeah, watch it.

3.12: Jus in Bello - ditto

3.13: Ghostfacers - lots of people hate this one. I find it refreshing and lots of fun, knowing how much the actors enjoyed doing it.

3.14: Long-Distance Call - enh. Skippable.

3.15: Time Is on My Side - ew, except for meeting a recurring character.

3.16: No Rest for the Wicked - necessary, but watch through the fingers at times.

My Totally Subjective List.

3.16: No Rest for the Wicked - necessary, but watch through the fingers at times.

Watch through the fingers how? Because of the gore?

I wouldn't skip any of them if I hadn't seen the whole series, personally. I might not rewatch all of them later, but I would hate having holes.

Because Dean's insides aren't as pretty as his outsides?

I hate that season, but may rewatch due to discussion here.

Well, the physical and the emotional gore. It's pretty damned rough, but I think it's necessary for what follows.

Going through episode by episode, there were so many scenes that I wanted to lift, because of both the overarching series mythology and the season arc, or because of a brother bonding moment, or an element of backstory, or a funny moment, or a bit of clever dialog, or because of some geeky techical or digital wizardry. There were several eps I think are ultimately disposable, but they have a toad scene, or a panic attack, or a cougar scene--which bothered a lot of people, but I found uncomfortably funny, because of the actors involved. If I could cherry-pick scenes from S3 and stitch them together in a narrative whole, excluding some of the rage-making stuff, it might make me happy. But I realize, going through the list, that there's more there to like than I remembered. It's just some scenes that I hated. But I hated them a lot and they colored how I felt about the ep, which bled into my memories of the season.

3.13: Ghostfacers - lots of people hate this one. I find it refreshing and lots of fun, knowing how much the actors enjoyed doing it.

I loved this one, I must confess.

I guess I'm easy? There's not one episode I hate. There are a few that bore me now, like Bugs, but even that I'd watch before almost anything else going.

And Show has never pushed my buttons the way it has with others, so. I can see the issues most of the time, I just don't really feel them.

I'm re-recording season one but so far I've deleted every episode without watching except Home.

I guess hate is too strong a word for what I feel for S3 really. I was more bored by it than anything. I would watch the episodes and be glad that I had seen the Winchesters but nothing blew me away like it had in the previous two seasons. Then S4 started off so awesome that I realized it wasn't just me getting tired of the show. It could be that awesome again. And it has been for me ever since.

Rewatching the early seasons is a treat if for nothing else seeing how much the boys have grown both physically and as actors. Also early seasons have JDM, which, yeah. ::sigh::

I ran across this vid last night. [link]

I love that the Impala is Christopher Robin.

MM is the only one I pretend doesn't exist.