You're right, and I stand (both abashed and) corrected; JA was a featured cast member on DA. It still was only a single season, and JP had been in the featured credits (and presumably paid more) for several seasons.

But yes, I nod vehement agreement that JA's characters had impressed me far more than JP's wussy Dean had. I had not seen Young McGyver, Flight of the Phoenix nor, thankfully, New York Minute by then. I have seen FotP since, but although I watched Devour for JA, I refuse to sit through Cry Wolf or House of Wax or NYMinute for JP. I did watch a few eps of that teen series JA played a clueless cutie on, though. Mr. Something. Frightening how dumb the character was, and how effortless JA made that seem.

Sam: Because I know you!
Dean: Really?
Sam: Because I've been following you around my entire life! I mean, I've been looking up to you since I was four, Dean, studying you, trying to be just like my big brother. So, yeah, I know you. Better than anyone else in the entire world. And this is exactly how you act when you're terrified. And I mean I can't blame you. It's just...
Dean: What?
Sam: It's just I wish you would drop the show and be my brother again. 'Cause...just 'cause.

::sniff::

I love the look on JP's face as Dean calls Sam to come look under the hood of the car. Before the explanation starts he has this look of patient expectancy that's so...younger sibling. And the heartbreak on his face when Dean explains what he's doing.

Yeah, the way he's so naturally leaning in to do whatever it is and pauses, thinks, makes that decision, and then looks at Sam. And Sam is exactly the little brother there, ready to assist, even if it's boring, and then ...

I think the way Dean settles onto the cooler as he says, "Put your shoulder into it," is what really breaks me.

For me it's the look on Dean's face after Sam leans in and starts work on the engine. He looks so...it's almost closed, but it's sad and it's old and it's responsible. And I think it's a little proud.

Aw. Yes, that too.

IT'S THE WHOLE SCENE, OKAY.

I should do my S2 top five.

I've been reading all your lists and marvelling at your ability to winnow down the episodes into bite-sized chunks of goodness. I think for me it would be easier to go through and pick out the episodes that don't make any kind of best-of list.

I am just now watching that scene!

So much sniff

I think for me it would be easier to go through and pick out the episodes that don't make any kind of best-of list.

This seems like a totally worthwhile exercise as well!

I still like the idea of a list of favorite *scenes* rather than episodes. I'd need at least ten for each season for that one.

Amy, me too, especially since it would give me an excuse to relive all my favorite scenes.