Aw, I liked all of them but especially Luke. I don't think I would like Lorelei or Rory if they were actually in my life talking to me all the time, mind you, but safely behind the screen of my TV I liked them.

And Luke I loved.

I loved Luke as well. Just thought he made a wrong decision letting Dean go forward with the wedding considering what he knew.

I generally loved Lorelei because she was so empowered. When she was kind of victim-y toward the last regarding Luke, I didn't like that at all and was ready to see strong Lorelei again, which kind of happened.

But I LOVE Sam Winchester much more than Rory's Dean. Then again, now that JP has had all this experience, I wonder if he would put some nuances into Rory's Dean to make him more interesting.

I have watched GG on reruns to get all the Dean talk that has gone on here. I haven't seen any JA episodes of DA or Smallville.

I never watched Dawson's Creek (oh, the delicious Pacey I missed!) and I'd sort of like to watch JA's season in that.

I've watched DA for him, and he's awesome as Alec, but DA is so not my beautiful show.

I only ever watched the series finale of Dawson's Creek. Why I felt I had to do that, I cannot explain. But I still think of him as Pacey now that he's on Fringe.

I'm going to get all pedantic.

Lorelai.

Of course, even the back of the S1 DVDs spells it wrong...

JA is marvellous as Alec, and was pretty great as Ben too. I just couldn't bear the lead, and the show was cracktastic (not usually in the good way). The idea of putting him in a love triangle in season 3 would have been fun, though. He didn't stand out for me at the time on Dawson's Creek--I thought he was fine enough, but I was all about Pacey 24/7.

Wasn't he kissing up on Lana in Smallville? I blank her scenes. But he was, as always, pretty to look at.

Suzi, JA is absolutely beautiful in Dark Angel. I think he is at his most beautiful. But like Amy said, to watch it is a commitment to a show that may not be your cup of tea. I was okay with it. I liked the dog friend. Joshua?

I never saw JA on Dawson's creek, but I did see him on Smallville and was really really bored with his character. I even skipped episodes during his run. He and Lana were together and it was just a big snooze fest.

then again, I watched a shitload of Dark Angel for him, so I have no high ground

You still might--Do you own Devour?

I think he is at his most beautiful.

Yes. But I think I like how he looks better now. I like the filling out and the crinkles.

Damn, he was pretty though, with the floppy hair.