The Futoncritic is listing their top 50 episodes of 2008 - check out what was 28-26:
28/27/26. "supernatural: ghostfacers/monster movie/wishful thinking" (the cw)
(originally aired: april 24, 2008/october 16, 2008/november 6, 2008)
It's probably not a coincidence that our three favorite episodes of "Supernatural" came from the same dude: Ben Edlund. These episodes featured everything from a suicidal teddy bear, Dracula using a coupon to pay for his pizza and unrequited gay love from beyond the grave. Said events ranged from downright silly to unexpectedly dramatic and gave the show a decidedly unique voice. Sure the main draw of "Supernatural" is two guys, a Chevy Impala and a trunk full of weapons fighting the things that go bump in the night, but darn if Edlund's installments don't take us on their own quirky path.