I think Home out-creepied any creepy that any show past, present, or future is likely to come up with. I still get a full-body shudder thinking of that one.

Oh yeah. The only thing I've seen on TV to rival Mrs. Peacock's reveal was Ronette Pulaski waking from her coma and having flashbacks to BOB.

Home was the first X files episode I ever saw. It took at least a year before anyone could convince me to watch others.

I do have to say I'm glad American Horror Story didn't leave me with nightmares--marathoning it wasn't the safest choice, but I congratulate Tim et al (what? I'm biased...) on pulling off scary and creepy and gross on a really consistent basis.

Did you watch both seasons?

No, still at the start of S2.

I don't know that the second one can top the first for scares, but in terms of sheer WTFery it may outdo anything that Ryan Murphy—and thus the human race as a whole—has ever achieved before.

To say the very least.

Although, there's always S3 to come!

So, three months until new Show?

Heaven is closed with Metatron in charge. All angels are cast out and supposedly human? Human babes, or stuck in vessels without powers/with powers? Cas is separated by unknown distance from the Winchesters, Sam has not completed his trials, and so is still in a weakened unhealbable state?

Where the F is my speculative fic, peoples?!

And Crowley is an emo demon, and Kev's a bit gunshy.

Sooo much potential, and no ones's touching it?

I read one fic that was post-(failed)-trials that didn't address it beyond "failed" and really bad wincest.