Because almost every curtain fic I've read (and some I've imagined writing) makes hunting impossible
I've read a mad amount where they just decide to hang up their shotguns. And I don't like them. It makes me anxious and sad for the characters. I know there are fans that think that hunting is the unhappy ending for them, and there's no way they can resolve their issues and still keep on in *any* sort of a hunting lifestyle.
But I don't agree.
I guess I just don't like curtain fic.
Give me a story where they age out, but don't renounce the life and I much prefer it.
I also don't get much out of stories where they remove all the supernatural elements from the world as the result of whatever happens at the end of a given season, and then that's why they have to retire, but then they discover "Oh! This is kind of nice, now that I think about it! We should have done this earlier!"
I want equitable hunters, dammit. I'm not asking for happy, of course, because I have my issues, but I am not asking for that much broken misery. I want Dean to keep drinking, carousing, and shooting things. I want him to not deal all *that* well with his anger. That's who I like, dammit. Sam, I think of as much healthier. I don't need his pain for my amusement so much.
Both of them, Sam especially, were more broken in that fic than makes me happy.
I didn't get too far into it. It's just not my sort of beautiful cake. But I am not really reading fic right now anyway, so I can't tell if it's general avoidance, or specific to that fic. But Roque does tend to do more damage to them than I'm comfortable with.